Websink Prep UKKS2 ScienceYear 3 chaptersScience textbooksYear 1Year 2Year 3Year 4Year 5Year 6Year 7Year 8Year 9Browse allPast papersFind a tutorBecome a tutor
Primary Science · Year 3Chapter 1 · Working scientifically
Year 3 · Chapter 1

Working scientifically

By the end of this chapter you will be able to

  • Ask questions that I can test, and say which type of enquiry would answer them
  • Plan a fair test: change one thing, measure the result, and keep everything else the same
  • Take careful observations and accurate measurements, using standard units
  • Record, sort and present my results in a table, a key, a bar chart or a labelled diagram
  • Write a report, a conclusion and a prediction that match my results, and suggest an improvement
  • Compare differences and similarities, and say which evidence supports an idea

You should already know

  • Asking simple questions and making a fair test (Year 2 Science, Chapter 1)
  • Measuring with a ruler and reading scales, and reading simple tables and bar charts (Year 2 Maths and Science)

Where this leads

  • Planning fair tests and using evidence in the plant and light chapters of this book (Chapters 2 to 8)
  • Using a range of enquiries and more precise measurements in Year 4 Working scientifically

National Curriculum for England, Key Stage 2 science, Year 3. Content: WS1 ask relevant questions and use different types of scientific enquiries to answer them, WS2 set up simple practical enquiries, comparative and fair tests, WS3 make systematic and careful observations and take accurate measurements using standard units, with thermometers and data loggers, WS4 gather, record, classify and present data in a variety of ways, WS5 record findings using simple scientific language, drawings, labelled diagrams, keys, bar charts and tables, WS6 report on findings, with oral and written explanations, displays and conclusions, WS7 use results to draw simple conclusions, make predictions for new values, suggest improvements and raise further questions, WS8 identify differences, similarities or changes related to simple scientific ideas and processes, WS9 use straightforward scientific evidence to answer questions or to support findings.

Exercise P  Do you remember?

1
FName the tool you would use to measure the length of a pencil.
2
FAli changes the cup and the water in a test. Is this a fair test? Write yes or no.
3
FHow many marks are in this tally?
4
RWhich is the odd one out: 3 cm, 7 cm, 2 kg or 9 cm? Write the odd one out.
5
FWhich tool measures how long something takes?
1.1

Asking relevant questions

Year 3
Ask relevant questions, Use different types of scientific enquiries to answer them
Video lesson: Asking relevant questionsComing soon
Story. Class 3C walks around the school field after the rain. Each pupil writes one question on a card. Mia asks, “Which puddle is the deepest?” Jack asks, “Is the field the best place to play?” Ella asks, “How much water will be left in the puddle tomorrow?” Their teacher says that some questions can be tested, and some cannot.

A relevant question is one about the thing we are studying. We can answer it with evidence: facts that we have measured, observed or read in a reliable source.

“Is the field the best place to play?” is an opinion. People can disagree about it, so it is not a science question.

Scientists answer questions in different ways. These are the types of enquiry that you will meet in this book:

Type of enquiryWhat we doExample question
Comparative and fair testchange one thing, measure the result and compare the resultsWhich paper towel soaks up the most water?
Observing over time (practice only)look at the same thing again and again, and record what changesHow much water is left in a jar each day?
Pattern seeking (practice only)look at the results and find what goes togetherDo taller stacks of books have more books?
Secondary sources (practice only)use a book or a reliable website, with a grown-up, to find facts that others have recordedWhat do pandas eat?

Practice only: observing over time, pattern seeking and secondary sources are practice for this chapter. They are not separate statements, but they help you use the enquiry skills in the rest of the chapter.

Key ideas

  • A relevant question is about the thing we are studying, and we can find its answer with evidence.
  • An opinion, such as “Which is the best?”, is not a science question.
  • A comparative test compares results for different things. A fair test changes only one thing.
  • Observing over time, pattern seeking and secondary sources are practice only.
Worked example 1.1.1
Which paper towel soaks up the most water? What type of enquiry would answer it?

Method. Look for a question that we can test by comparing results.

  1. Is it about what we are studying? It is about paper towels and water, so it is relevant.
    paper towels and water
  2. Can we test it? We can use the same water on each towel and compare the results.
    compare the towels
  3. Choose the type of enquiry. We compare different towels in a test, so it is a comparative test.
    comparing towels
  4. Write the answer.
    comparative and fair test

Check. We change the towel and measure the water. ✓

Watch out. A comparative test compares different things. A fair test changes only one thing.

Worked example 1.1.2
Is the field the best place to play? Is this a science question?

Method. Look for the word that asks for a personal view.

  1. Look for the word best. Best is what someone likes, so the question asks for an opinion.
    best = opinion
  2. Ask if a test can give one answer. People disagree about the best place, so no test gives one answer.
    no single answer
  3. Write the answer.
    No, it is an opinion

Check. An opinion is not a science question. ✓

Worked example 1.1.3
How much water has gone from the jar each day this week? Which type of enquiry is this?

Method. Look for words that ask about change over time.

  1. Look at the words each day. The question asks what happens again and again, over time.
    each day, this week
  2. Match it to an enquiry type. We look at the same jar many times and record the change. This is practice only.
    same jar, many days
  3. Write the answer.
    observing over time (practice only)

Check. We look at the same jar again and again. ✓

Watch out

Watch out: a question can be relevant and still be hard to test. Ask yourself: can we measure, observe or find a reliable source that gives the answer?

Try it at home or school (with a grown-up). Go for a short walk outside, or look out of a window. Each of you writes one question about something you see. Choose one question that you can answer with evidence. Say which type of enquiry would answer it.

Exam tip

Grown-up tip. When your child asks a question, ask: “Can we find out by testing, measuring or looking?” Help them decide if it is an opinion or a question we can answer.

Exercise 1A  Relevant questions and types of enquiry

1
FWhich question can we answer with a ruler? A: Which bird is the best? B: How long is this leaf?
2
FIs “Which colour is the nicest?” a science question? Write yes or no.
3
FWhich type of enquiry would answer “Which paper towel soaks up the most water?” Write the type.
4
FIs “Are cats better than dogs?” an opinion or a relevant question? Write opinion or relevant.
5
FWhich type of enquiry is “How much water is left in the jar each day?” Write the type.
6
FMatch each question to its type of enquiry.
(a)Which of two balls bounces higher?
(b)What do pandas eat?
(c)Do the taller stacks have more books?
7
PSAsk a relevant question that you could test about the water in a jar. Write one question.
8
FWhich is not a relevant question for a test of plant growth? A: How tall is the plant after one week? B: Is this plant pretty?
9
FTom asks, “How many books are on the shelf?” Can he answer it by counting? Write yes or no.
10
RElla asks, “Do the tallest towers fall first?” Which type of enquiry would help her look for a pattern: observing over time, pattern seeking or secondary sources? Write one.
11
RSam says that a question about the best colour is a science question. Is Sam right? Write no, and give a short reason.
12
RWorking scientifically. Write a relevant question about how fast a snail moves on wet paper and on dry paper. It must be a comparative test.
1.2

Setting up a fair test

Year 3
Set up simple practical enquiries, comparative and fair tests
Video lesson: Setting up a fair testComing soon
Story. Class 3C wants to find out which paper towel soaks up the most water. Mia says, “Let us pour water on three different towels.” Jack says, “We must make it fair, or the test will not tell us anything.” They agree on the same size squares, the same amount of water, the same tray and the same pouring height.

A fair test is a test in which only one thing changes. We change the one thing we want to test. We measure what happens, and we keep everything else the same.

A comparative test compares the results for different things, such as three kinds of towel. If only the towel changes, the test is also a fair test.

A fair test helps us trust the answer. If we changed two things, we could not tell which one made the difference.

CHANGEone thing only:the kind of towelMEASUREthe ml of waterthat drips intothe trayKEEP THE SAME10 cm by 10 cm squares100 ml of watersame traysame pouring height
Change one thing, measure the result, and keep everything else the same.

Key ideas

  • In a fair test, only one thing changes.
  • Measure the result of the change in the same way each time.
  • Keep the other things the same: the size, the amount, the place and the way the test is done.
  • If two things change, we cannot tell which one made the difference.
Worked example 1.2.1
Ben tests whether a sponge or a cloth soaks up more water. He uses a big sponge and a small cloth. Is this a fair test? Write yes or no.

Method. Find the things that are different between the two tests.

  1. Read the material. The sponge and the cloth are different materials.
    material changes
  2. Read the size. The sponge is big and the cloth is small, so the size also changes.
    size changes too
  3. Write the answer.
    no

Check. Two things changed: the material and the size. ✓

Watch out. Use the same size of sponge and cloth, so that only the material changes.

Worked example 1.2.2
In the bounce test, every ball is dropped from 50 cm. Which thing changes in this test: the ball or the drop height?

Method. Find the thing that stays the same, then the thing that changes.

  1. Read the drop height. The drop height is 50 cm for every ball, so it stays the same.
    drop: 50 cm every time
  2. Find the thing that changes. The ball is different each time, so the ball changes.
    ball changes
  3. Write the answer.
    the ball

Check. The drop height stays at 50 cm. ✓

Worked example 1.2.3
In the towel test, which of these should stay the same? A: the kind of towel B: the amount of water C: the pouring height

Method. Find the thing we change, and the things we keep the same.

  1. Read A. The kind of towel is the thing we change, so it does not stay the same.
    A: changes
  2. Read B and C. The amount of water and the pouring height are kept the same.
    B and C: same
  3. Write the answer.
    B and C

Check. Only the towel changes. ✓

Watch out

Watch out: a pupil who uses a bigger towel as well as a different kind of towel has changed two things. Check every thing before you start.

Try it at home or school (with a grown-up). Use three paper towels or kitchen cloths of the same size. Put a tray under each one. Pour the same amount of water (for example, 100 ml from a measuring jug) onto each one, from the same height. Compare how much water drips into the tray.

Exam tip

Grown-up tip. Ask your child: “What are we changing? What are we keeping the same?” Let them point to each thing as they name it.

Exercise 1B  Fair tests and comparative tests

1
FIn a test of which paper towel soaks up the most water, what do we change?
2
FIn the same test, what do we measure?
3
FA pupil pours 100 ml onto one towel and 50 ml onto another. Is this a fair test? Write yes or no.
4
FWhich thing should stay the same in the towel test: the kind of towel or the size of the squares?
5
FName one thing to keep the same in a bounce test.
6
FWhich of these is a comparative test? A: Does a red cup hold more water than a blue cup? B: Is a cup nice?
7
FAhmed changes three things in one test: the colour, the size and the weight. Is this a fair test? Write yes or no.
8
FAnswer both parts.
(a)How many things should change in a fair test? Write the number.
(b)What should happen to everything else?
9
PSLook at the table. Which two tests are a fair comparison of the towels?
TestTowelWater poured (ml)Size of square (cm)
1Cloth10010 by 10
2Sponge10010 by 10
3Cloth15010 by 10
10
PSWorking scientifically. Write one plan for a test of which ball bounces highest. Which one thing will you change?
11
PSThree towels were each given 100 ml of water. The ml that dripped into the tray was: Towel A 30 ml, Towel B 12 ml and Towel C 45 ml. Which towel soaked up the most?
12
RYasmin says, “We changed the towel and the pouring height, but the test is still fair because both changes are small.” Is Yasmin right? Write no, and explain.
1.3

Careful observations and accurate measurements

Year 3
Make systematic and careful observations, Take accurate measurements using standard units, with thermometers and data loggers
Video lesson: Careful observations and accurate measurementsComing soon
Story. In Class 3C a data logger sits on the windowsill. Every hour it records the room temperature, all day, without anyone writing the numbers down. At the end of the day the class reads the record. Then they measure the water in a jar and the length of a stick, using careful measurements.

An observation is something we notice with our senses or with a tool. A careful observation looks closely, uses the same method each time, and records exactly what we see.

A measurement is a number with a unit, such as 7 cm, 60 ml or 18 °C. We use standard units: centimetres (cm), millilitres (ml), grams (g), kilograms (kg), seconds, minutes and degrees Celsius (°C).

To measure accurately:

18 °C11 amdata logger
A data logger
A data logger records a reading at set times, without a person writing each one down.

A thermometer measures temperature. The liquid inside rises when it gets warmer. A measuring cylinder measures the volume of a liquid in millilitres (ml). A data logger is a small electronic device that records readings, such as temperature, at set times.

Practice only: observing over time means looking at the same thing again and again and writing down what changes. It is practice for careful observation, and it is not a separate statement.

Key ideas

  • Use standard units, and write the unit with every measurement.
  • Start a ruler at 0 and read it at eye level.
  • A thermometer measures temperature in degrees Celsius (°C).
  • A data logger records readings at set times, without a person.
Worked example 1.3.1
What temperature does this thermometer show?
°C051015202530

Method. Read the scale, then find the mark that the red liquid reaches.

  1. Find the scale. The numbers go up in steps of 5, with a small mark for each degree.
    0, 5, 10, 15, 20, 25, 30
  2. Find the level of the red liquid. The liquid stops above the 15 mark, at the third small mark.
    above 15
  3. Count the marks above 15. Three small marks above 15 make 18.
    15 + 3 = 18
  4. Write the answer.
    18 °C

Check. The thermometer reads 18 degrees, the same as the data logger at 11 am. ✓

Watch out. Read the number on the scale, then add the small marks. Do not guess.

Worked example 1.3.2
The stick starts at 0 on the ruler. How long is it?
012345678910

Method. Start at 0, then read the other end of the stick.

  1. Find the 0 mark. Measuring starts at 0, so the stick begins at 0.
    starts at 0
  2. Read the other end. The end of the stick is at the 7 cm mark.
    ends at 7
  3. Write the length with the unit. A length is written in centimetres, cm.
    7 cm
  4. Write the answer.
    7 cm

Check. Count along the ruler from 0 to 7, one centimetre at a time. ✓

Watch out. If you do not start at 0, the answer will be wrong.

Worked example 1.3.3
How many ml of water are in the measuring cylinder?
ml020406080100

Method. Find the scale, then read the level of the water.

  1. Find the scale. The numbers go up in steps of 20 ml, with a mark every 10 ml.
    0, 20, 40, 60, 80, 100
  2. Find the water level. The blue line is at the mark for 60 ml.
    blue line at 60
  3. Write the answer with the unit. The volume of a liquid is measured in ml.
    60 ml
  4. Write the answer.
    60 ml

Check. The blue line sits level with the 60 mark. ✓

Watch out. Read the scale at eye level. Looking from above or below can give a wrong number.

Watch out

Watch out: a measurement with no unit does not say what was measured. “7” could mean 7 cm, 7 ml or 7 °C.

Try it at home or school (with a grown-up). Pour 100 ml of water into a jar, using a measuring jug. Put a strip of tape on the jar to mark the water level. Look at the jar at the same time each day for a few days, and write down the level. (This is practice only: observing over time.)

Exam tip

Grown-up tip. Ask: “What is the unit? Where does the scale start? Can you read it again, at eye level?”

Exercise 1C  Careful observations and accurate measurements

1
FWhat temperature does this thermometer show?
°C051015202530
2
FHow long is the stick? It starts at 0.
012345678910
3
FHow many ml of water are in this measuring cylinder?
ml020406080100
4
FWhich unit is best for measuring the mass of a pencil case: g or km? Write the unit.
5
FWhich tool measures temperature? Write its name.
6
FAnswer both parts.
(a)Which is the same length: 6 cm or 60 mm?
(b)Which is heavier: 1 kg or 900 g?
7
FWhat must we do to read a measuring cylinder accurately? Write eye level or from above.
8
FWhich of these is a measurement in standard units? A: four spoons B: 4 cm
9
FA data logger shows 17 °C at 10 am. Does someone have to be there to write this reading down as it happens? Write yes or no.
10
FEach day Ruby marks the water level in a jar and writes it in a table. Which is the better record: one reading, or a table with a level for each day? Write the better record. (practice only: observing over time)
11
RWorking scientifically. Aisha reads a ruler at a slant and says the pencil is 7 cm long. Ben reads it at eye level from 0 and says 6 cm. Who should measure again, and why?
12
RWorking scientifically. Write one sentence that describes a careful observation of a leaf, with a unit or a tool.
1.4

Recording, classifying and presenting data

Year 3
Gather, record, classify and present data in a variety of ways, Record findings using simple scientific language, drawings, labelled diagrams, keys, bar charts and tables
Video lesson: Recording, classifying and presenting dataComing soon
Story. Class 3C sorts five objects for a display. Each object is made of one material. Jack says, “If we make a key, anyone can sort the objects without asking us.” The class also draws a bar chart of the water soaked up by the towels, and labels a diagram of the bounce test.

When we record results, we write them down straight away, in a table, with units. When we classify, we put things into groups using a rule.

A key is a set of yes or no questions. You answer each question in order, and each answer leads you to a group. A key helps other people sort things in the same way.

We can present data in different ways:

ObjectMaterial
wooden rulerwood
metal paper clipmetal
plastic cupplastic
wooden spoonwood
cardboard boxcardboard
The five objects and the material each one is made of.
Is it made of wood?Is it made of metal?WOODwooden rulerwooden spoonMETALpaper clipOTHERplastic cupcardboard boxyesnoyesno
A key for sorting the five objects into wood, metal or other.

Key ideas

  • A table records each thing and its result, with a unit.
  • A key uses yes or no questions, in order, to sort things into groups.
  • A bar chart needs a title, labels and a scale.
  • A labelled diagram names each part, so that a reader can understand it.
Worked example 1.4.1
Use the key. Which group is a wooden spoon in?

Method. Start at the top of the key and follow the answers.

  1. Start at the top. The first question is: is it made of wood?
    Is it made of wood?
  2. Answer the question for the spoon. A wooden spoon is made of wood, so the answer is yes.
    wood: yes
  3. Follow the yes arrow. A yes takes us to the wood group, so we stop there.
    wood group
  4. Write the answer.
    wood

Check. The wooden spoon is in the wood group. ✓

Watch out. Start at the top every time, and answer the first question for each object.

Worked example 1.4.2
Use the bar chart. How many ml did Towel B soak up?
050100150Towel A70Towel B88Towel C55Water soaked up (ml)

Method. Find the bar for Towel B, then read the top of the bar on the scale.

  1. Find the bar for Towel B. It is the middle bar.
    Towel B
  2. Read the top of the bar. The bar reaches the 88 mark on the scale, in ml.
    88 ml
  3. Write the answer.
    88 ml

Check. Towel B soaked up 88 ml, the most of the three. ✓

Watch out. Read the value on the bar, and write the unit ml.

Worked example 1.4.3
Look at the labelled diagram. From what height is the ball dropped?
ruler, cmtabledrop 50 cmball0102030405060

Method. Find the label on the dashed line, then check the ruler.

  1. Find the label. The label on the dashed line says drop 50 cm.
    drop 50 cm
  2. Check the ruler. The dashed line lines up with the 50 mark on the ruler.
    50 on the ruler
  3. Write the answer.
    50 cm

Check. The label and the ruler both show 50 cm. ✓

Watch out

Watch out: a bar chart without a title or units cannot be read properly. Always write what the numbers mean.

Try it at home or school (with a grown-up). Find five things from around your home that are made of different materials, such as wood, metal, plastic, paper or cloth. Make a yes or no key to sort them into groups. Ask someone else to sort the things using your key.

Exam tip

Grown-up tip. Ask your child to read each question of the key aloud, in order. If a thing does not fit, ask them to change the key, not the answer.

Exercise 1D  Recording, classifying and presenting data

1
FUse the key. Which group is a plastic cup in? Write the group.
Is it made of wood?Is it made of metal?WOODwooden rulerwooden spoonMETALpaper clipOTHERplastic cupcardboard boxyesnoyesno
2
FHow many objects are made of wood? Use the table.
ObjectMaterial
wooden rulerwood
metal paper clipmetal
plastic cupplastic
wooden spoonwood
cardboard boxcardboard
3
FHow many objects are in the metal group?
4
FHow many objects are in the other group?
5
FWrite the number shown by this tally.
6
PSThe table below is part of a record. Write the missing number for the metal group.
GroupNumber of objects
wood2
metal?
other2
7
FLook at the labelled diagram. What does the ruler measure?
ruler, cmtabledrop 50 cmball0102030405060
8
FWhich is the best way to show the water soaked up by three towels: a bar chart, or a list with no units? Write the best way.
9
FUse the bar chart. How many ml did Towel C soak up?
050100150Towel A70Towel B88Towel C55Water soaked up (ml)
10
FUse the key. Which group does a metal paper clip go in? Write the group.
Is it made of wood?Is it made of metal?WOODwooden rulerwooden spoonMETALpaper clipOTHERplastic cupcardboard boxyesnoyesno
11
RWorking scientifically. Design a yes or no question that puts the cardboard box into its own group. Write one question.
1.5

Reporting findings and drawing conclusions

Year 3
Report on findings from enquiries, including oral and written explanations, displays and presentations of results and conclusions, Use results to draw simple conclusions, make predictions for new values, suggest improvements and raise further questions
Video lesson: Reporting findings and drawing conclusionsComing soon
Story. Mia presents the towel test to the class. She says what they did, shows the results on a bar chart, and says what the results mean. Jack suggests a way to make the test fairer. The class then chooses one new question to test next time.

A report tells other people what you did and what you found. It can be spoken or written, and it can include a display of your results. Use the same order each time:

Question
→
What we did
→
What we found
→
What it means
→
Next question
The parts of a report, in order.

A conclusion is a short sentence that says what the results show. It must match the results, not what you wish had happened.

A prediction is a sensible guess about a new value, based on a pattern in your results. We check it by testing. For example, if each book in a stack is 3 cm thick, we can predict the height of 5 books: 5 × 3 cm = 15 cm.

To suggest an improvement, think about what made the test less fair or less accurate, and how to fix it. To raise a further question, ask a new question that the test makes you wonder about.

Key ideas

  • A report says what we did, what we found, what it means and what we will test next.
  • A conclusion must match the results.
  • A prediction is a guess based on a pattern, and we test it to check it.
  • Suggest improvements, and raise further questions.
Worked example 1.5.1
The results were: Towel A soaked up 70 ml, Towel B 88 ml and Towel C 55 ml. Write the conclusion.

Method. Find the biggest result, then say what it shows.

  1. Find the biggest amount. Towel B soaked up 88 ml, which is the most.
    88 ml is the biggest
  2. Write a sentence about the results. The conclusion says what the results show.
    Towel B soaked up the most water
  3. Write the answer.
    Towel B soaked up the most water.

Check. The conclusion matches the biggest result, 88 ml. ✓

Watch out. A conclusion is not what you hoped would happen. It is what the results show.

Worked example 1.5.2
In the book stack test, 1 book was 3 cm high, 2 books were 6 cm and 3 books were 9 cm. Predict the height of 5 books.

Method. Use the pattern in the test: each book adds the same height to the stack.

  1. Find the pattern in the results. Each book is the same thickness, so the stack grows by the same amount.
    1 book = 3 cm; 2 books = 6 cm; 3 books = 9 cm
  2. Predict the height for 5 books. Multiply the thickness of one book by 5.
    5 × 3 = 15
  3. Write the answer.
    15 cm

Check. Add 3 cm for each book: 5 books is 15 cm. ✓

Watch out. A prediction is a sensible guess from the pattern. It is only checked when we measure it.

Worked example 1.5.3
Jack says the towels were not all poured at the same speed. What would make the test fairer?

Method. Find the thing that changed, then choose a fix that keeps it the same.

  1. Find the thing that changed. The pouring speed changed, which is a second thing that changed.
    pouring speed
  2. Choose a fix. Pour at the same speed for every towel, so only the towel changes.
    same speed
  3. Write the answer.
    Pour at the same speed for every towel

Check. Only the towel now changes. ✓

Watch out

Watch out: a prediction is not proof. It is a guess that we must test. Always say that a prediction is a guess until it is tested.

Try it at home or school (with a grown-up). Stack identical books, or identical boxes, one on top of another. Measure the height of the stack with a ruler after one, two and three. Predict the height of four, then check it by measuring.

Exam tip

Grown-up tip. Ask your child to tell you the story of their test in three sentences: what we did, what we found, what it means.

Exercise 1E  Reporting, conclusions and predictions

1
FWrite one sentence to report the result for Towel B. Use the number 88 ml.
2
FWhich is a conclusion: “Towel B soaked up the most water.” or “I liked Towel B best.” Write the conclusion.
3
PSPredict the height of 6 identical books, each 3 cm thick, if the pattern continues.
4
PSThe water level in a jar was 80 ml on day 1, 72 ml on day 2 and 64 ml on day 3. Predict the level on day 4.
Dayml left in the jar
Day 180
Day 272
Day 364
(Practice only: pattern seeking.)
5
FSuggest one improvement for the bounce test. Write one improvement.
6
FWhich is a good further question after the towel test? A: Does a thicker towel soak up more water? B: What colour is the tray?
7
FIs this conclusion correct for the results 70 ml, 88 ml and 55 ml? “Towel A soaked up the most water.” Write yes or no.
8
FAnswer both parts.
(a)Which towel soaked up the least?
(b)How much did it soak up?
9
PSA pupil says, “Each book makes the stack 3 cm taller.” Use this pattern to predict the height of 8 books.
10
RElla says that her test proves all towels soak up the most water when they are thick. Is she right? Write no, and explain.
11
RWorking scientifically. Write a conclusion for the bounce test. The rubber ball bounced 38 cm and the sponge ball bounced 9 cm.
1.6

Differences, similarities and evidence

Year 3
Identify differences, similarities or changes related to simple scientific ideas and processes, Use straightforward scientific evidence to answer questions or to support findings
Video lesson: Differences, similarities and evidenceComing soon
Story. Class 3C drops a rubber ball and a sponge ball from the same height, 50 cm. Both balls are round, but they bounce to different heights. Jack says, “The rubber ball bounces higher, and our results show it.” Mia asks, “Can one test show that for all balls?” The class looks at the evidence.

To compare two things, look for differences (what is not the same) and similarities (what is the same). A change is something that becomes different over time, or after a test.

Evidence is information that helps us answer a question or support an idea. Measurements from our own test are evidence. So are facts from a reliable source, checked with a grown-up.

FeatureRubber ballSponge ball
Shaperoundround
Materialrubbersponge
Bounce from 50 cm38 cm9 cm
Comparing the rubber ball and the sponge ball.

Evidence supports a finding when it points to the same answer. One test with one of each ball is some evidence, but it is not enough to be sure about all balls.

Practice only: pattern seeking means looking across your results for things that go together, such as taller stacks having more books. Secondary sources means finding facts in a book or a reliable website, checked with a grown-up. These are practice only, and they are not separate statements.

Key ideas

  • A difference is something that is not the same.
  • A similarity is something that is the same.
  • Evidence is measured, or reliable, information that helps to answer a question.
  • One test is not always enough to prove something for all cases.
Worked example 1.6.1
Which is a difference between the rubber ball and the sponge ball? A: both are round B: they bounce to different heights

Method. Decide which statement describes something that is not the same.

  1. Read A. Both balls are round, so this is a similarity.
    A: same
  2. Read B. The rubber ball bounced to 38 cm and the sponge ball to 9 cm, so the heights are different.
    B: different
  3. Write the answer.
    B

Check. The bounce heights are different. ✓

Worked example 1.6.2
Name one thing the two balls have in common, from the table.

Method. Find a feature that is the same in both columns.

  1. Look at the shape. The table says round for both balls.
    round: rubber, round: sponge
  2. Find the same thing. The same word in both columns is a similarity.
    round = round
  3. Write the answer.
    both are round

Check. The shape is the same for both balls. ✓

Worked example 1.6.3
Does the evidence (rubber ball 38 cm, sponge ball 9 cm) support the idea that the rubber ball bounces higher? Write yes or no.

Method. Read the evidence, and check whether it supports the idea.

  1. Read the evidence. The rubber ball bounced to 38 cm.
    38 cm
  2. Compare it with the other ball. The sponge ball bounced to only 9 cm, so the rubber ball bounced higher in this test.
    38 is more than 9
  3. Write the answer.
    yes

Check. The measurements point to the same answer. ✓

Watch out

Watch out: “I think” is not evidence. A measurement is evidence, because someone else can measure it again and check it.

Try it at home or school (with a grown-up). Drop two different balls from the same height, with a grown-up. Measure how high each one bounces, using a ruler. Write one difference and one similarity from your results. Then decide whether one test is enough to say what happens for all balls.

Exam tip

Grown-up tip. Ask: “Is that a measurement or a guess? How could someone else check it?”

Exercise 1F  Differences, similarities and evidence

1
FName one difference between the rubber ball and the sponge ball, using the table in the text.
2
FWhich ball bounced lower?
3
PSHow many cm higher did the rubber ball bounce than the sponge ball?
4
FWhich is evidence? A: The sponge ball is nicer. B: The sponge ball bounced to 9 cm. Write A or B.
5
FIs this a measurement or an opinion? “The rubber ball bounced to 38 cm.” Write measurement or opinion.
6
RPractice only, pattern seeking. The book stacks were: 1 book 3 cm, 2 books 6 cm and 3 books 9 cm. Does the height go up as more books are added? Write yes or no.
7
FWhich is the better place to find a fact for a report? A: a book by an expert, or a reliable website a grown-up has checked. B: a guess from a friend. Write A or B. (practice only: secondary sources)
8
FAnswer both parts.
(a)Which ball bounced higher?
(b)Which unit should we use to compare the bounce heights: cm or ml?
9
RDoes one test with two balls prove that rubber balls always bounce higher? Write yes or no.
10
PSTowel A soaked up 70 ml and Towel C soaked up 55 ml. How many ml more did Towel A soak up than Towel C?
11
RWorking scientifically. Mia says rubber balls always bounce higher than sponge balls. Use our test to explain why she cannot be sure.
12
RWorking scientifically. Write one question that looks for a pattern in our results. Say whether it is practice only.

Chapter summary

SkillMethod
Ask relevant questionsA relevant question is about what we study and can be answered with evidence. Know the type of enquiry to use.
Fair testChange one thing, measure the result and keep everything else the same.
Measure carefullyUse standard units, start a ruler at 0, read at eye level, and use a thermometer, a measuring cylinder or a data logger.
Record and classifyRecord results at once, with units. Sort things with a key of yes or no questions.
Present dataUse a table, a bar chart, a labelled diagram or a drawing. Give it a title and labels.
Report and concludeSay what you did and found. Write a conclusion that matches the results. Predict from a pattern, then test.
Compare and use evidenceFind differences and similarities. Use evidence from tests to answer a question or support a finding.

Can you…?

  • I can ask a question that I can test, and say which type of enquiry would answer it
  • I can set up a fair test in which only one thing changes
  • I can measure with standard units, and read a scale at eye level
  • I can use a thermometer, a measuring cylinder and a data logger
  • I can record, classify and present data in a table, a key, a bar chart or a labelled diagram
  • I can write a report, a conclusion and a prediction that match my results
  • I can suggest an improvement and raise a further question
  • I can compare differences and similarities, and use evidence to support an idea

Key terms

relevant question
a question about the thing we are studying that we can answer with evidence
enquiry
a way of finding out, such as a test, an observation or a search in a reliable source
fair test
a test in which only one thing changes and everything else is kept the same
comparative test
a test that compares the results for different things
observation
something we notice with our senses or with a tool
measurement
a number with a unit, such as 7 cm or 60 ml
thermometer
a tool that measures temperature in degrees Celsius
data logger
a small electronic device that records readings at set times
key
a set of yes or no questions used to sort things into groups
conclusion
a short sentence that says what the results show
prediction
a sensible guess about a new value, based on a pattern, which we then test
evidence
information from measurements or reliable sources that helps answer a question
practice only
an enquiry skill used as practice in this chapter, which is not a separate statement

Exercise 1Z  Check-up

1
Which is a relevant science question? A: Is the tray pretty? B: How much water soaks into the towel?
2
In a fair test of paper towels, which thing must stay the same? Write the thing.
3
What temperature does this thermometer show?
°C051015202530
4
Use the key. Which group does a wooden ruler go in? Write the group.
Is it made of wood?Is it made of metal?WOODwooden rulerwooden spoonMETALpaper clipOTHERplastic cupcardboard boxyesnoyesno
5
Use the bar chart. How many ml did Towel A soak up?
050100150Towel A70Towel B88Towel C55Water soaked up (ml)
6
Towel B soaked up 88 ml and Towel C soaked up 55 ml. How many ml more did Towel B soak up than Towel C?
7
A stack of identical books is 3 cm thick for each book. Predict the height of 5 books if the pattern continues.
8
Working scientifically. Write one sentence that is a conclusion for the towel test. Towel B soaked up 88 ml and Towel C soaked up 55 ml.
9
The rubber ball bounced 38 cm and the sponge ball bounced 9 cm. Which ball bounced higher? Write the ball.
10
Which measuring tool records readings by itself, at set times? Write the name.
18 °C11 amdata logger

Total 16 marks. Allow about 16 minutes.

Exercise 1X  Practice test questions

1
FIn a fair test comparing three kinds of paper towel, what is the one thing we change? Write it.[1 mark]
2
FWhich tool should you use to measure 60 ml of water? A: ruler B: measuring cylinder[1 mark]
3
RLook at the table. Which two tests are a fair comparison, and why?
TestBallDrop heightBounce height
1rubber ball50 cm38 cm
2sponge ball50 cm9 cm
[2 marks]
4
FWhat temperature does this thermometer show?
°C051015202530
[1 mark]
5
FUse the bar chart. How many more objects are in the wood group than in the metal group?
00.511.522.5wood2metal1other2Objects in each group
[1 mark]
6
PSA stack of 3 identical boxes is 36 cm high. Predict the height of 5 identical boxes if the pattern continues.[2 marks]
7
RRuby says a data logger is better than writing numbers by hand. Give one reason, using what you learned in this chapter.[2 marks]
8
RJack says, “The stick measured 7 cm.” What must be true about how the ruler was used for this measurement to be accurate?[2 marks]
9
RTowel A soaked up 70 ml, Towel B 88 ml and Towel C 55 ml. Which statement is supported by these results? A: Towel C soaked up the most water. B: Towel B soaked up the most water. Write A or B.[1 mark]
10
PSPlan a fair test to find which of two sponges soaks up the most water. Write one thing you change, one thing you measure and one thing you keep the same.[3 marks]

Websink Prep UK is an independent site. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by AQA, Pearson Edexcel, OCR, WJEC, Eduqas, CCEA, SQA, GL Assessment, CEM or the Department for Education. All exam board names and trademarks belong to their owners. Past papers are linked from the exam boards' own websites and are not hosted here.

About Websink Prep UK · Find a tutor · Privacy · Terms · Cookie settings