Working scientifically revisited
By the end of this chapter you will be able to
- Ask a question that can be answered by a test, and make a prediction with a reason
- Plan a fair test: change one thing, measure the result, and keep everything else the same
- Read a measuring cylinder in millilitres and a thermometer in degrees Celsius carefully
- Record results in a table, and present them in a bar chart with a title and a scale
- Work out an average, and say what a conclusion should be based on
- Say how a test could be made more reliable
You should already know
- Fair tests, and changing only one thing at a time (Year 3 Science, Chapter 1)
- Using a ruler, a thermometer and a bar chart in Year 3 (Year 3 Science, Chapters 1 and 9)
Where this leads
- Living things, and how they are grouped (Year 4 Science, Chapter 2)
- Every practical in Year 4 uses these skills: keys, circuits, melting and evaporation
National Curriculum for England, Key Stage 2 science, Year 4. Content: WS (shared with Year 3): ask relevant questions and use different types of scientific enquiries to answer them, WS: set up simple practical enquiries, comparative and fair tests, WS: make systematic and careful observations, and take accurate measurements using standard units, WS: gather, record, classify and present data in a variety of ways to help in answering questions, WS: report and present findings, and use results to draw simple conclusions, WS: identify differences, similarities or changes related to simple scientific ideas and processes.
Exercise P Do you remember?
Method. Think about the part of the plant that is under the soil.
- Read the chapter about plant parts. The roots take in water and minerals from the soil.roots
- Write the answer. roots
Check. The stem carries the water up, but the roots take it in. ✓
Method. Think about the green, flat parts of a plant.
- Read the chapter about plant parts. The leaves use light, water and air to make food for the plant.leaves
- Write the answer. leaves
Check. The stem holds the plant up, and the leaves make its food. ✓
Method. Think about the direction of the force.
- Read the definition. A pull moves something towards the person pulling.pull
- Write the answer. pull
Check. A push moves something away from the person pushing. ✓
Method. Think about where animals get their food.
- Read the chapter about food. Animals cannot make their own food. They get nutrition from what they eat.no
- Write the answer. no
Check. Plants make their own food, and animals must eat. ✓
Method. Think about the place an object moves across.
- Read the definition. A surface is the top layer that an object moves on.surface
- Write the answer. surface
Check. A carpet and a tray are both surfaces. ✓
Asking questions and predicting
Scientists begin with a question. A good scientific question can be answered by a test or by careful observation. It is a question that you can measure, such as: “How many millilitres of water does this towel soak up?”
Before the test, scientists make a prediction. A prediction says what you think will happen, and why. It is a guess that is based on an idea, so it can be tested. After the test, you compare the results with your prediction.
Key ideas
- A scientific question is one that can be answered by a test or by careful observation.
- A prediction says what you think will happen, and why.
- A prediction is written before the test, so you can compare it with the results.
- A question that can be measured makes a good scientific question.
Method. Think about whether you can measure the answer.
- Think about the answer. We can measure how many millilitres of water each towel soaks up.measure the millilitres
- Decide. Because we can measure the answer, the question can be tested.can be tested
- Write the answer. yes
Check. A question that can be tested by measuring is a good scientific question. ✓
Method. Read what Aisha wrote.
- Find the words “I think”. Aisha says what she thinks will happen, before the test.before the test
- Decide. Something said before the test, with a reason, is a prediction.prediction
- Write the answer. prediction
Check. A measurement is something you read off a scale during the test. ✓
Method. Check which question you can measure.
- Look at a). You cannot measure which towel is the nicest, because that is an opinion.opinion
- Look at b). You can measure how much water each towel soaks up.measure
- Write the answer. b
Check. Question b) can be answered by a fair test. ✓
Watch out
Watch out: a question about what someone likes is an opinion. It cannot be answered by measuring, so it is not a scientific question to test.
Try it at home or school (with a grown-up). Choose two things at home that might soak up water, such as a tea towel and a sponge. Ask a question about them, such as: “Which one soaks up more water?” Write one prediction before you test. You will test it in section 1.2.
Exam tip
Grown-up tip. Ask: “What do you think will happen? Why do you think that?” Let your child write a prediction with a reason, and check it after the test.
Exercise 1A Asking questions and predicting
Method. Think about whether the answer can be measured.
- Read the question. The question asks for an amount of water, which can be measured in millilitres.an amount
- Decide. So the question can be tested, and the answer is yes.yes
- Write the answer. yes
Check. Millilitres are a measurement, so the question can be tested. ✓
Method. Think about which question has an answer you can measure.
- Look at a). A favourite is an opinion, so it cannot be measured.opinion
- Look at b). The number of millilitres can be measured.can be measured
- Write the answer. b
Check. Only b) asks for a measurement. ✓
Method. Read the definition of a prediction.
- Read the definition. A prediction says what you think will happen, and why.happen
- Write the answer. happen
Check. A prediction is written before the test, not after. ✓
Method. Think about when the words are written.
- Think about the words. Aisha says what she thinks will happen, before the test.before the test
- Decide. So the words are a prediction.prediction
- Write the answer. prediction
Check. A measurement is written down during the test, after you read the scale. ✓
Method. Look for the question you can measure.
- Look at a) and c). Prettiest and oldest cannot be answered by measuring water.cannot be measured
- Look at b). We can measure the water soaked up by each towel.can be measured
- Write the answer. b
Check. The answer to b) is found by measuring the water. ✓
Method. Read the sentence.
- Read the sentence. Mo says what he thinks will happen, and gives a reason.thinks will happen
- Decide. Saying what will happen, with a reason, is a prediction.prediction
- Write the answer. prediction
Check. A question would end with a question mark, and Mo does not ask one. ✓
Method. Read the start of section 1.1.
- Read the key idea. A scientific question is one that can be answered by a test or by careful observation.answered
- Write the answer. answered
Check. Testing gives us an answer to the question. ✓
Method. Check which question has a measurable answer.
- Look at a). Whether a colour is nicest is an opinion.opinion
- Look at b). We can measure the water each one soaks up, and compare them.compare
- Write the answer. b
Check. The second question can be answered with a fair test. ✓
Method. Think about how scientists know things.
- Think about the idea. A scientist must test an idea to find out if it is true.test it
- Decide. Ruby has not measured the towels, so she should test before she is sure. The answer is no.no
- Write the answer. no
Check. A prediction must be tested before it becomes a result. ✓
Method. Make a prediction based on an idea.
- Choose a prediction. Choose yes or no, and then give a reason you can test.a reason
- Write it down. The prediction must be written before the test.before the test
- Write the answer. Accept any prediction with a sensible reason, such as: Yes, because darker towels hide more water; or No, because colour does not change how the paper soaks up water.
Check. You will check your prediction in a fair test. ✓
Method. Think of a question you can measure.
- Think of the thing to measure. We can measure the millilitres of water a towel soaks up.millilitres
- Write the question. Turn the measurement into a question with a question mark.question mark
- Write the answer. Accept any question that can be measured, such as: Which towel soaks up the most water?
Check. A good question can be tested and answered. ✓
Method. Think about what you do after the test.
- Think about the results. After the test you compare the results with your prediction.compare
- Write the reason. Writing the prediction first means it is not changed to match the results.not changed
- Write the answer. Accept any sentence that says a prediction is written before the test, so it can be compared with the results.
Check. Writing first keeps the test honest. ✓
Setting up a fair test
A fair test is a test where only one thing is changed. The thing we change is the variable we choose to change. The thing we measure is the result. Everything else must be kept the same, so that the test is fair.
We also repeat each test. Repeating the test (called a trial) helps us check that a result is not a one-off. We then find an average, which is the total divided by the number of trials.
This table shows how the three towels were tested. Each towel was dipped in the same 50 ml of water for 10 seconds, three times.
| Towel | Trial 1 (ml) | Trial 2 (ml) | Trial 3 (ml) | Average (ml) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Towel A | 9 | 11 | 10 | 10 |
| Towel B | 16 | 15 | 17 | 16 |
| Towel C | 12 | 14 | 13 | 13 |
Key ideas
- A fair test changes only one thing.
- The thing measured is the result, and everything else is kept the same.
- Repeat each test three times, and find the average.
- If two things change, the test is not fair.
Method. Find the thing that changes.
- Read the sentence. Ruby changes the brand of towel.brand of towel
- Name the part. The thing that is changed is the variable, so the variable is the brand.brand
- Write the answer. brand
Check. The water and the time are kept the same. ✓
Watch out. Measured and changed are different parts of a test.
Method. Count the things that change.
- Count the changes. Aisha changes two things: the towel and the amount of water.two things
- Decide. A fair test changes only one thing, so this test is not fair.not fair
- Write the answer. no
Check. A fair test changes only one thing. ✓
Method. Read the sentence about the trials.
- Read the sentence. Ruby does three trials for each towel.three trials
- Write the number. So she does three trials for one towel.three
- Write the answer. 3
Check. Three trials for each towel, with the average found from them. ✓
Watch out
Watch out: a test is only fair if you keep everything else the same. Changing the water, the time and the towel at once tells you nothing about any one of them.
Try it at home or school (with a grown-up). Choose a plastic lid and a sheet of paper towel. Put 20 ml of water on each one, using a spoon, with a grown-up. Change only the surface, and keep the water and the time the same. Write down what you kept the same.
Exam tip
Grown-up tip. Ask: “What did you change? What did you keep the same?” Let your child name the variable, the result and one thing that was kept the same.
Exercise 1B Setting up a fair test
Method. Read the definition of a fair test.
- Read the definition. A fair test is a test where only one thing is changed.only one thing
- Write the answer. 1
Check. Changing one thing means we know what caused the result. ✓
Method. Count the things that change.
- Count the changes. Ruby changes two things: the towel and the water.two things
- Decide. A fair test changes only one thing, so the answer is no.no
- Write the answer. no
Check. Two changes make the result impossible to explain. ✓
Method. Read the key idea in section 1.2.
- Read the key idea. Everything else must be kept the same, so the test is fair.kept the same
- Write the answer. same
Check. Same means it does not change between trials. ✓
Method. Read the table in section 1.2.
- Read the first column. The result is the thing we measure, which is the millilitres of water soaked up.measured
- Check the words. Measured is the word for the result.measured
- Write the answer. measured
Check. Changed is the one thing we choose to change. ✓
Method. Think about what stays the same in every trial.
- Think about the test. Each towel uses the same amount of water and the same time.same amount of water
- Write one thing. For example, the amount of water must stay the same.amount of water
- Write the answer. Accept any one of: the amount of water, the time, the size of the towel.
Check. Keeping one thing the same makes the test fair. ✓
Method. Look at what changes.
- Look at the cubes. Mo changes the size of the cube, which is a thing he should keep the same.size
- Decide. Because the size changes between tests, the test is not fair. The answer is no.no
- Write the answer. no
Check. The size of the cube must be kept the same. ✓
Method. Look at the table.
- Read the columns. The table has columns for trial 1, trial 2 and trial 3.trial 1, 2 and 3
- Count them. There are three trials.3
- Write the answer. 3
Check. Three trials help us find a reliable average. ✓
Method. Think about the test Ali did.
- Read his test. Ali changed two things, so we cannot tell which one caused the result.two things
- Decide. His conclusion is not sound because the test was not fair.not sound
- Write the answer. no
Check. Only one thing should change in a fair test. ✓
Method. Look at the timers.
- Look at the timers. Each towel had its own timer, so the time was not the same for each.not the same
- Write the problem. The time was not kept the same, so the test is not fair.time
- Write the answer. Accept any answer that says the time was not kept the same, because each towel used a different timer.
Check. Using the same timer for every test keeps the time the same. ✓
Method. Think about one thing you could change.
- Think of one thing. The amount of water, or the place, could be changed.one thing
- Write it down. Only one thing should be changed in a fair test.only one
- Write the answer. Accept any one thing, such as the amount of water in the puddle, or the place where it is.
Check. Changing only that one thing keeps the test fair. ✓
Method. Think about one result.
- Think about one trial. One result can be unusual, by chance.unusual
- Write the reason. Repeating the test shows whether the result happens again, and the average is more reliable.more reliable
- Write the answer. Accept any sentence that says repeating shows whether a result is typical, and makes the average more reliable.
Check. Three trials give a better answer than one. ✓
Measuring carefully
Careful measuring gives us accurate results. Use the right unit: millilitres (ml) for water in a measuring cylinder, and degrees Celsius (°C) for temperature on a thermometer.
To read a measuring cylinder, put it on a flat table, and read the bottom of the curved surface of the water at eye level. To read a thermometer, keep the bulb in the liquid, and do not let it touch the bottom or the sides of the container.
Key ideas
- Read a measuring cylinder in millilitres (ml), at eye level.
- Read a thermometer in degrees Celsius (°C), with the bulb in the liquid.
- Use a ruler in centimetres (cm) to measure length.
- A measurement needs a number and a unit.
Method. Read the scale at eye level.
- Find the level. The top of the water is at the line that is 40 ml on the scale.40 ml
- Check the unit. The reading is in millilitres, so the number is 40.millilitres
- Write the answer. 40
Check. The line between 30 and 50 is 40 ml. ✓
Method. Find the red liquid on the scale.
- Find the top of the liquid. The red liquid goes up to a point between 20 and 30.between 20 and 30
- Read the scale. The top of the liquid is two small marks above 20. Each small mark is 2 degrees, so the reading is 24 degrees Celsius.24
- Write the answer. 24
Check. Two small marks above 20, at 2 degrees each, make 24 degrees. ✓
Watch out. Read the top of the red liquid, not the bottom of the bulb.
Method. Add the extra length to the pencil.
- Read the lengths. The pencil is 9 cm, and the towel is 4 cm longer.9 cm and 4 cm
- Add them. 9 cm plus 4 cm makes 13 cm.9 + 4 = 13
- Write the answer. 13
Check. Check: 13 cm minus 4 cm is 9 cm. ✓
Watch out. Include the unit, centimetres, when you write the answer.
Watch out
Watch out: read the scale at eye level. Looking from above or below makes the level look higher or lower than it really is.
Try it at home or school (with a grown-up). Put 100 ml of water into a jug, using a measuring jug with a grown-up. Pour 40 ml into a cup and read the level with your eyes at the same height. Check your reading with a grown-up. Do not use hot water.
Exam tip
Grown-up tip. Ask: “What is the unit? Is your eye level with the water?” Let your child read the scale at eye level, and say the number and the unit together.
Exercise 1C Measuring carefully
Method. Read the level of the water.
- Find the line. The water level is at the 40 ml mark.40 ml
- Write the number. The number is 40.40
- Write the answer. 40
Check. The mark between 30 and 50 is 40. ✓
Method. Read the red liquid on the scale.
- Find the top of the liquid. The red liquid is between 20 and 30 degrees Celsius.between 20 and 30
- Read the mark. The top of the liquid is at 24 degrees Celsius.24
- Write the answer. 24
Check. The reading is two small marks above 20, and each small mark is 2 degrees. ✓
Method. Think about what a measuring cylinder measures.
- Think about the unit. Water in a measuring cylinder is measured in millilitres.millilitres
- Write the answer. ml
Check. Cm is used for length, not for water. ✓
Method. Think about what a thermometer measures.
- Think about the measurement. A thermometer measures temperature, in degrees Celsius.temperature
- Write the answer. degrees Celsius
Check. Litres are used for volume, not temperature. ✓
Method. Read the key idea in section 1.3.
- Read the key idea. Read the water at eye level, so the reading is not too high or too low.eye level
- Write the answer. eye level
Check. Looking from above or below gives a wrong reading. ✓
Method. Count up the marks in steps of 10.
- Find 40 on the scale. The scale goes 30, 40, 50 in steps of 10 ml.40, 50
- Name the next mark. The next mark above 40 is 50 ml.50
- Write the answer. 50
Check. Steps of 10 ml from 40 give 50. ✓
Method. Take the water away from the starting amount.
- Read the starting amount. The cylinder starts with 35 ml of water.35 ml
- Take away the pouring. 35 minus 10 is 25, so 25 ml is left.35 - 10 = 25
- Write the answer. 25
Check. Check: 25 ml plus 10 ml makes 35 ml. ✓
Method. Add the three trials, then divide by three.
- Add them. 40 plus 42 plus 41 makes 123.40 + 42 + 41 = 123
- Divide by three. 123 divided by 3 is 41.123 divided by 3 is 41
- Write the answer. 41
Check. Check: 41 + 41 + 41 = 123. ✓
Watch out. Divide by the number of trials, which is three.
Method. Count the measurements.
- Read the sentence. Aisha measured the paper towel, and then measured it again.measured again
- Count them. She made two measurements of the same length.2
- Write the answer. 2
Check. Repeating the measurement helps us check it. ✓
Method. Think about what the bulb should be in.
- Think about the bulb. The bulb should be in the liquid, not touching the cup.in the liquid
- Decide. A bulb touching the bottom measures the cup, so the reading is not correct.not correct
- Write the answer. no
Check. Keep the bulb in the liquid, away from the sides and the bottom. ✓
Method. Think about the number 40 on its own.
- Think about the number. The number 40 could mean 40 ml, 40 cm or 40 degrees.could mean
- Write the reason. The unit tells us what the measurement is, so the answer is clear.unit
- Write the answer. Accept any sentence that says a unit tells us what the number means, such as millilitres or centimetres.
Check. A number with a unit is a measurement. ✓
Recording and presenting results
A table records results in rows and columns. Every table needs a title and clear headings for each column. Use a table to write down the counts before you draw a chart.
A bar chart shows the counts as bars. It needs a title, a label under each bar, and a scale along one side that shows the numbers. The taller the bar, the bigger the count.
The class counted the leaves they found. Here is the table.
| Type of leaf | Number counted |
|---|---|
| Sycamore | 7 |
| Oak | 5 |
| Birch | 3 |
| Horse chestnut | 6 |
| Total | 21 |
Key ideas
- A table has a title and clear headings for each column.
- A bar chart has a title, labels under each bar and a scale.
- To classify means to sort things into groups.
- Add the counts in a table to find the total.
Method. Find the row for sycamore.
- Find the row. The row for sycamore says 7.sycamore: 7
- Read the number. So the class counted seven sycamore leaves.7
- Write the answer. 7
Check. Sycamore has the largest count, 7, and the tallest bar on the chart. ✓
Watch out. Read the number in the column, not the name of the leaf.
Method. Add the four counts.
- Add them in pairs. Seven plus five is 12, and three plus six is 9.7 + 5 = 12, 3 + 6 = 9
- Add the two totals. Twelve plus nine is 21.12 + 9 = 21
- Write the answer. 21
Check. The total in the table is 21. ✓
Method. Find the shortest bar.
- Look at the bars. The shortest bar is the one with the smallest count, which is 3.smallest count
- Read the label. The label under the shortest bar is Birch.Birch
- Write the answer. Birch
Check. The count for birch is 3, the smallest in the table. ✓
Watch out
Watch out: a bar chart without a scale does not tell you the numbers. Always check the numbers on the scale before you read a bar.
Try it at home or school (with a grown-up). Collect five different leaves from a garden or park, with a grown-up. Sort them into groups by type, or by size. Count each group, and write the counts in a table with a title. Wash your hands after you touch the leaves.
Exam tip
Grown-up tip. Ask: “What is the title of your table? What does each column show?” Let your child find the total by adding the counts, and check it.
Exercise 1D Recording and presenting results
Method. Find the row for oak.
- Find the row. The row for oak says 5.oak: 5
- Write the number. So five oak leaves were counted.5
- Write the answer. 5
Check. Check the bar for oak on the bar chart; it reaches 5 on the scale. ✓
Method. Find the smallest number in the table.
- Look at the numbers. The numbers are 7, 5, 3 and 6, so the smallest is 3.3
- Read the name. The number 3 is in the row for birch.Birch
- Write the answer. Birch
Check. Birch had the shortest bar on the chart. ✓
Method. Add the four numbers in the column.
- Add them. 7 plus 5 plus 3 plus 6.7 + 5 + 3 + 6
- Find the total. The total is 21 leaves.21
- Write the answer. 21
Check. The table total also says 21. ✓
Method. Find the number 5 in the table.
- Find the number. The number 5 is in the row for oak.row for oak
- Write the name. So the leaf with 5 counted is oak.Oak
- Write the answer. Oak
Check. No other type has a count of 5. ✓
Method. Count the rows that name a type of leaf.
- Count the rows. Sycamore, oak, birch and horse chestnut are the four rows.four rows
- Write the number. There are four types of leaf.4
- Write the answer. 4
Check. The total row is not a type of leaf. ✓
Method. Read the key idea in section 1.4.
- Read the key idea. A bar chart has a scale along one side that shows the numbers.scale
- Write the answer. scale
Check. The scale shows the number each bar stands for. ✓
Method. Find the tallest bar.
- Look at the bars. The tallest bar is for the most counted leaf, which is 7.7
- Read the label. The label under the tallest bar is Sycamore.Sycamore
- Write the answer. Sycamore
Check. Sycamore has the biggest count in the table. ✓
Method. Compare the two numbers.
- Read the numbers. Horse chestnut is 6, and birch is 3.6 and 3
- Compare them. 6 is bigger than 3, so there were more horse chestnut leaves.more
- Write the answer. more
Check. Six is more than three. ✓
Method. Subtract the smaller count from the larger count.
- Read the two counts. Sycamore is 7, and birch is 3.7 and 3
- Subtract. 7 minus 3 is 4, so there were 4 more sycamore leaves.7 - 3 = 4
- Write the answer. 4
Check. Check: 3 plus 4 makes 7. ✓
Method. Compare the two counts.
- Read the counts. Oak is 5, and sycamore is 7.5 and 7
- Decide. 7 is more than 5, so there were more sycamore leaves, and Ali is not right.not right
- Write the answer. no
Check. Sycamore had the biggest count of all. ✓
Method. Read the words about tables.
- Read the key idea. Every column of a table needs a clear heading.heading
- Write the answer. heading
Check. A heading says what the column is about. ✓
Method. Think about the table and the bar chart.
- Think about the table. The table keeps every count in one place, in order.in order
- Write the reason. So the bar chart can show each count accurately.accurately
- Write the answer. Accept any sentence that says a table keeps the counts in order, so the bar chart can be drawn accurately.
Check. The chart is drawn from the table. ✓
Conclusions and evaluation
A conclusion answers the question that the test asked. It must be based on the results, not on a guess. A good report says what was done, what was found, and what the conclusion is.
To evaluate a test, ask: was it fair? Did the results match the prediction? Could a result be wrong? How could the test be made better? This is how scientists check their work.
Key ideas
- A conclusion answers the question the test asked, and is based on the results.
- Find differences by comparing two results.
- Three trials are more reliable than one trial.
- To evaluate, ask whether the test was fair and how it could be improved.
Method. Subtract the smaller average from the larger one.
- Read the averages. Towel B averages 16 ml, and Towel A averages 10 ml.16 and 10
- Subtract. 16 minus 10 is 6, so Towel B soaks up 6 ml more.16 - 10 = 6
- Write the answer. 6
Check. Check: 10 plus 6 makes 16. ✓
Watch out. Subtract the smaller number from the larger number.
Method. Look at the averages.
- Find the largest average. The largest average is 16 ml, which is Towel B.16 ml
- Write the conclusion. So the conclusion is that Towel B soaks up the most water.Towel B
- Write the answer. Towel B
Check. The bar for Towel B is the tallest on the chart. ✓
Method. Think about what one trial can show.
- Think about one trial. One trial can give a result that is unusual, by chance.unusual
- Think about three trials. Three trials show whether a result is typical, and their average is more reliable.typical
- Write the answer. Accept any reason that says three trials show whether a result is typical, and that the average is more reliable.
Check. Three trials make a better test than one trial. ✓
Watch out
Watch out: a conclusion must match the results. Do not write that a towel is the best if the test did not measure what makes a towel good.
Try it at home or school (with a grown-up). Repeat the paper towel test from section 1.2 with two towels of your own, with a grown-up. Keep the same water and the same time, and do three trials. Find the average for each towel, and write one conclusion from your results. Say one thing that could make your test better.
Exam tip
Grown-up tip. Ask: “What did your results show? How sure are you? What would you change next time?” Let your child write the conclusion in one sentence, using the words from the results.
Exercise 1E Conclusions and evaluation
Method. Subtract the smaller average from the larger one.
- Read the averages. Towel B is 16 ml, and Towel A is 10 ml.16 and 10
- Subtract. 16 minus 10 is 6.16 - 10 = 6
- Write the answer. 6
Check. Check: 10 plus 6 is 16. ✓
Method. Find the smallest average.
- Look at the averages. The averages are 10, 16 and 13 ml.10 ml is the smallest
- Read the name. The smallest average, 10 ml, is for Towel A.Towel A
- Write the answer. Towel A
Check. Towel A has the shortest bar on the chart. ✓
Method. Compare the two averages.
- Read the averages. Towel C is 13 ml, and Towel B is 16 ml.13 and 16
- Compare them. 13 is smaller than 16, so Towel C soaks up less.less
- Write the answer. less
Check. Thirteen is less than sixteen. ✓
Method. Look at the averages.
- Find the largest average. The largest average is 16 ml.16 ml
- Write the name. The towel with 16 ml is Towel B.Towel B
- Write the answer. Towel B
Check. A conclusion answers the question the test asked. ✓
Method. Add the three trials, then divide by three.
- Add them. 9 plus 11 plus 10 makes 30.9 + 11 + 10 = 30
- Divide by three. 30 divided by 3 is 10.30 divided by 3 is 10
- Write the answer. 10
Check. Check: 10 + 10 + 10 = 30. ✓
Method. A conclusion says what the results show.
- Look at a). Towel B soaked up the most water, which is what the results show.results show
- Look at b). Testing next week is a plan, not a conclusion from results.a plan
- Write the answer. a
Check. A conclusion is based on the results of the test. ✓
Method. Look at the three trials for Towel B.
- Read the trials. The three trials for Towel B are 16, 15 and 17 ml.16, 15, 17
- Find the biggest. The biggest of these is 17 ml.17
- Write the answer. 17
Check. The average of the three is 16 ml, so 17 is above it. ✓
Method. Read the key idea in section 1.5.
- Read the key idea. A conclusion answers the question the test asked.question
- Write the answer. question
Check. The question is the starting point of the test. ✓
Method. Think about how many trials are needed.
- Think about one trial. One trial can be unusual, so one result is not enough to be sure.not enough
- Decide. Mo should repeat the test to check the result, so the answer is no.no
- Write the answer. no
Check. Three trials and an average are more reliable. ✓
Method. Think about how much evidence there is.
- Think about the test. Three trials on one day is a small amount of evidence.small amount
- Write the reason. The result might not be typical, so “always” claims too much.too much
- Write the answer. Accept any reason that says the test used only three trials, so the result might not be typical.
Check. A conclusion should not claim more than the evidence shows. ✓
Method. Think about what would make the results more trustworthy.
- Think about the test. More trials, or the same method each time, make the results more reliable.more reliable
- Write one way. Choose one change and write it as a sentence.one change
- Write the answer. Accept any way, such as repeating more trials, or using the same method and the same water each time.
Check. Evaluating a test helps us improve it. ✓
Method. Think about what a conclusion is.
- Think about the results. The results are the evidence that the conclusion uses.evidence
- Write the reason. A conclusion that does not match the results is not supported by evidence.supported
- Write the answer. Accept any sentence that says the conclusion should be based on the results, so that the evidence supports it.
Check. Good scientists check that their conclusion follows from the evidence. ✓
Chapter summary
| Skill | Method |
|---|---|
| Asking questions | A scientific question can be answered by a test. Write a prediction, with a reason, before the test. |
| Fair tests | Change one thing, measure one result, and keep everything else the same. Repeat each test three times. |
| Measuring | Read a measuring cylinder in ml at eye level. Read a thermometer in degrees Celsius with the bulb in the liquid. |
| Recording | Record results in a table with a title and headings. Show them in a bar chart with a scale. |
| Conclusions | A conclusion answers the question the test asked, and is based on the results. Evaluate the test to improve it. |
Can you…?
- I can ask a question that can be answered by a fair test
- I can write a prediction with a reason, before a test
- I can say which thing to change, which result to measure, and what to keep the same
- I can read a measuring cylinder in millilitres and a thermometer in degrees Celsius
- I can add up the counts in a table and find an average
- I can write a conclusion from my results, and say how the test could be improved
Key terms
- prediction
- what you think will happen in a test, and why, written before the test
- fair test
- a test where only one thing is changed, and everything else is kept the same
- variable
- a thing that can change in a test
- result
- the thing that is measured or found out in a test
- trial
- one run of a test, which is repeated to check the result
- average
- the total of several results, divided by the number of results
- conclusion
- a statement that answers the question the test asked, based on the results
- evaluate
- to think about how good a test was, and how it could be improved
- table
- a way of recording results in rows and columns, with a title and headings
- scale
- the numbers along the side of a chart or a measuring tool
Exercise 1Z Check-up
Method. Read the key idea in section 1.1.
- Read the definition. A prediction says what you think will happen, and why.prediction
- Write the answer. prediction
Check. A prediction is written before the test. ✓
Method. Read the level of the water at eye level.
- Find the line. The top of the water is at the 40 ml mark.40 ml
- Write the number. The number is 40.40
- Write the answer. 40
Check. The mark between 30 and 50 is 40. ✓
Method. Read the top of the red liquid.
- Find the top of the liquid. The liquid is between 20 and 30 degrees Celsius.between 20 and 30
- Read the scale. The liquid is at 24 degrees Celsius.24
- Write the answer. 24
Check. Two small marks above 20, at 2 degrees each. ✓
Method. Compare the two averages.
- Read the averages. Towel B is 16 ml, and Towel C is 13 ml.16 and 13
- Compare them. 16 is bigger than 13, so Towel B soaks up more.Towel B
- Write the answer. Towel B
Check. Sixteen is more than thirteen. ✓
Method. Think about what is kept the same.
- Think about the test. Everything except the one changed thing must stay the same.stay the same
- Write one thing. For example, the amount of water.amount of water
- Write the answer. Accept any one of: the amount of water, the time, the size of the towel.
Check. Only the towel is changed in a fair test. ✓
Method. Add the four counts.
- Add them. 7 plus 5 plus 3 plus 6.7 + 5 + 3 + 6
- Find the total. The total is 21.21
- Write the answer. 21
Check. Check: 21 is the total in section 1.4. ✓
Method. Look for the test that changes only one thing.
- Look at a). Changing the amount of water as well as the towel is not fair.not fair
- Look at b). Only the towel changes, so this is a fair test.only the towel
- Write the answer. b
Check. A fair test changes only one thing. ✓
Method. Read the definition in section 1.2.
- Read the definition. The result is the thing we measure in the test.result
- Write the answer. result
Check. The result is what the test finds out. ✓
Method. Add the three trials, then divide by three.
- Add them. 12 plus 14 plus 13 makes 39.12 + 14 + 13 = 39
- Divide by three. 39 divided by 3 is 13.39 divided by 3 is 13
- Write the answer. 13
Check. Check: 13 + 13 + 13 = 39. ✓
Watch out. Divide by the number of trials, not by the number of towels.
Method. Count the things that changed.
- Count the changes. The friend changed two things: the towel and the water.two things
- Decide. A fair test changes only one thing, so the test is not fair.not fair
- Write the answer. No. Accept any sentence that says two things were changed, so the test is not fair.
Check. Only one thing should change in a fair test. ✓
Total 18 marks. Allow about 18 minutes.
Exercise 1X Practice test questions
Method. Read the two words.
- Think about the test. The thing we measure is the result of the test.result
- Write the answer. result
Check. The changed thing is the one we choose to change. ✓
Method. Think about what a measuring cylinder measures.
- Think about the unit. Water in a measuring cylinder is measured in millilitres, which is ml.ml
- Write the answer. ml
Check. Cm is for length, not for water. ✓
Method. Read the description.
- Read the description. Changing one thing and keeping everything else the same is called a fair test.fair test
- Write the answer. fair test
Check. A fair test makes the results easier to explain. ✓
Method. Read the top of the red liquid.
- Find the top of the liquid. The liquid is between 20 and 30 degrees Celsius.between 20 and 30
- Read the scale. The liquid is at 24 degrees Celsius.24
- Write the answer. 24
Check. Two small marks above 20, at 2 degrees each. ✓
Method. Take the poured water away from the starting amount.
- Read the starting amount. The cylinder starts with 35 ml.35 ml
- Take away the pouring. 35 minus 10 is 25.35 - 10 = 25
- Write the answer. 25
Check. Check: 25 ml plus 10 ml is 35 ml. ✓
Method. Add the three results, then divide by three.
- Add them. 16 plus 15 plus 17 makes 48.16 + 15 + 17 = 48
- Divide by three. 48 divided by 3 is 16.48 divided by 3 is 16
- Write the answer. 16
Check. Check: 16 + 16 + 16 = 48. ✓
Method. Make a prediction based on an idea.
- Choose a towel. Choose the towel you think will soak up the least.the least
- Give the reason. Give a reason you can test.reason
- Write the answer. Accept any prediction with a reason, such as: Towel A, because its trials were the smallest.
Check. A prediction is written before the test. ✓
Method. Think about one result.
- Think about one trial. One trial can be unusual, by chance.unusual
- Think about three trials. Three trials show whether the result is typical, and the average is more reliable.typical
- Write the answer. Accept any reason that says three trials show whether a result is typical, and make the average more reliable.
Check. More trials give a more reliable answer. ✓
Method. Compare the two averages.
- Read the averages. Towel B averaged 16 ml, and Towel A averaged 10 ml.16 and 10
- Write the conclusion. Because 16 is bigger than 10, Towel B soaks up more water than Towel A.Towel B soaks up more
- Write the answer. Accept any conclusion that says Towel B soaks up more water than Towel A, because its average is higher.
Check. The conclusion matches the averages. ✓
Method. Find the largest count and add the counts.
- Find the largest count. Sycamore has the largest count, which is 7.Sycamore
- Add the counts. 7 plus 5 plus 3 plus 6 makes 21 leaves in total.21
- Write the answer. Accept any sentence that names sycamore as the most common leaf, and gives the total of 21 leaves.
Check. Sycamore was the most common, and there were 21 leaves in all. ✓