Working scientifically (Years 5-6)
By the end of this chapter you will be able to
- Name the changed variable, the measured variable and the fixed variables in a fair test
- Plan a fair test that changes only one variable
- Take repeat readings, find the mean, and spot a result that does not fit
- Read a measuring cylinder to the nearest millilitre
- Record data in tables and draw bar charts and line graphs with titles, labels and units
- Use results to make a prediction, and say what a further test would check
- Write a conclusion that matches the data, and say whether the evidence supports an idea
You should already know
- Fair tests, and changing only one thing at a time (Year 5 Science)
- Reading scales, and drawing simple tables and graphs (Years 3 to 5)
Where this leads
- Classifying living things with keys (Year 6 Science, Chapter 2)
- Every later Year 6 chapter uses these skills in its practical sections
National Curriculum for England, Key Stage 2 science, Year 6. Content: WS1 plan different types of scientific enquiries, including recognising and controlling variables, WS2 take measurements, using a range of scientific equipment, with increasing accuracy and precision, taking repeat readings when appropriate, WS3 record data and results using scientific diagrams and labels, classification keys, tables, scatter graphs, bar and line graphs, WS4 use test results to make predictions to set up further comparative and fair tests, WS5 report and present findings from enquiries, including conclusions, causal relationships and explanations, and degree of trust in results, WS6 identify scientific evidence that has been used to support or refute ideas or arguments.
Exercise P Do you remember?
Method. Think about the name for a test that is done carefully.
- Read the idea. A test where only one thing is changed is called a fair test.fair test
- Write the answer. fair test
Check. A fair test lets us say the change caused the result. ✓
Method. Think about the instrument that shows how hot or cold something is.
- Recall the name. A thermometer measures temperature in degrees Celsius.thermometer
- Write the answer. thermometer
Check. A thermometer is used for temperature, not for length. ✓
Method. Think about the scale on a measuring cylinder.
- Read the scale. Measuring cylinders are marked in millilitres.millilitres
- Write the abbreviation. The short form of millilitre is mL.mL
- Write the answer. mL
Check. A litre is 1000 millilitres, so mL is a small unit. ✓
Method. Think about the average of a set of results.
- Recall the word. The mean is the total of the results divided by the number of results.mean
- Write the answer. mean
Check. For 3 results, add them and divide by 3. ✓
Method. Think about a graph that shows change over time.
- Think about the shape. A line graph joins points that show a value at each time, so it shows a change over time.over time
- Write the answer. line graph
Check. A bar chart is better for comparing separate groups. ✓
Planning a fair test
In a fair test, we plan the test around variables. A variable is anything that could change in the test. There are three kinds:
- the changed variable is the one thing we change on purpose;
- the measured variable is the thing we measure to get our results;
- the fixed variables are all the other things, which we keep the same.
A fair test changes only one variable. If we change more than one thing, we cannot tell which one caused the result.
Key ideas
- A fair test changes only one variable.
- The changed variable is the one we change on purpose.
- The measured variable is what we measure to get the results.
- The fixed variables are kept the same, so the test is fair.
Method. Find the one thing that is changed on purpose.
- List the three choices. The type of towel, the amount of water and the time are the three choices.three choices
- Pick the one we change on purpose. Aisha and Tom choose different towels to compare, so the type of towel is changed.type of towel
- Write the answer. the type of towel
Check. The water and the time stay the same for every towel. ✓
Watch out. The amount of water and the time are fixed variables, not the changed variable.
Method. Check how many variables change.
- Compare the two tests. Two things change: the type of towel and the amount of water.towel and water
- Decide. A fair test changes only one variable, so this test is not fair.not fair
- Write the answer. no
Check. Only the amount of water should change in a test of the water. ✓
Method. Remember the rule for a fair test.
- Read the rule. A fair test changes only one variable.one variable
- Count the changed variables. Every other variable is a fixed variable, kept the same.one changed, the rest fixed
- Write the answer. 1
Check. Every other variable is a fixed variable, kept the same. ✓
Watch out
Watch out: the variable you measure is not the same as the variable you change. In the paper towel test you change the towel, and you measure the water absorbed.
Exam tip
Exam tip. When a question asks for a fair test, name the changed variable first, then at least one fixed variable.
Try it (with your teacher, or a grown-up at home). Put three small squares of different paper towel, or three pieces of kitchen paper of the same size, into three dishes with the same amount of water. Keep the size and the water the same. Predict which towel will soak up the most water, then leave them for one minute and look. Write down which variable you changed and which you kept the same.
Exercise 1A Planning a fair test
Method. Read the definition of the changed variable.
- Read the definition. The changed variable is the one thing we change on purpose.changed variable
- Write the answer. changed variable
Check. The changed variable is set by the person doing the test. ✓
Method. Read the definition of the measured variable.
- Read the definition. The measured variable is what we measure to get the results.measured variable
- Write the answer. measured variable
Check. For the paper towel test, the measured variable is the water absorbed. ✓
Method. Read the definition of the things kept the same.
- Read the definition. The fixed variables are kept the same in every test.fixed variables
- Write the answer. fixed variables
Check. Fixed variables make the test fair. ✓
Method. Think about what must be the same for every towel.
- Think about the test. The amount of water, the size of the towel and the time must be the same for every towel.the same for every towel
- Write one fixed variable. For example, use 50 mL of water for every towel.50 mL each time
- Write the answer. Accept any one of: the amount of water, the size of the towel, the time the towel is left in the water.
Check. Any of these would be a fixed variable. ✓
Method. Read the rule for a fair test.
- Read the rule. A fair test changes only one variable.only one
- Write the answer. one
Check. Changing two variables makes the result hard to explain. ✓
Method. Count the variables that change.
- Read the sentence. Ruby changes two things: the ramp and the car.two things
- Decide. Changing two things is not a fair test, so the answer is no.no
- Write the answer. no
Check. Only one thing should change, for example only the ramp. ✓
Method. Decide which thing Sam changes on purpose.
- Find the change. Sam chooses the height he drops the ball from.height of drop
- Find the measurement. The height of the bounce is what he measures.measured
- Write the answer. height of drop
Check. The height of the bounce is the measured variable. ✓
Method. Think about what else could affect the plant.
- Think about the plant. The type of plant, the water and the pot could all change growth.type, water, pot
- Write one fixed variable. Using the same type of plant keeps the test fair.same plant
- Write the answer. Accept any one of: the type of plant, the amount of water, the size of the pot.
Check. Keeping them the same means the sunlight is the only changed variable. ✓
Method. Find the thing Aisha changes on purpose.
- Read the plan. Aisha changes the temperature of the water on purpose.temperature
- Write the variable. So the changed variable is the temperature of the water.temperature of the water
- Write the answer. temperature of the water
Check. The time for the sugar to dissolve is the measured variable. ✓
Method. Count the changes in her plan.
- Count. Priya plans to change three variables.three
- Explain the problem. If the result changes, we do not know which change caused it.which change
- Write the answer. Accept any answer that says she changes three things at once, so she cannot tell which one made the difference.
Check. A fair test changes only one variable. ✓
Method. Think about cause and effect.
- Think about one changed variable. If only one thing changes, then any change in the result must come from it.one cause
- Compare with three. With three changes, we cannot tell which change caused the result.three causes
- Write the answer. Accept any sentence that says that with only one changed variable, any change in the results must come from that variable.
Check. One changed variable means one possible cause. ✓
Method. Check that only one variable changes.
- Read the test. Only the amount of water changes; the towel and the time stay the same.only water
- Decide. Because only one variable changes, the test is fair, so the answer is yes.yes
- Write the answer. yes
Check. The same towel and the same time were used. ✓
Method. Plan the test with one change.
- Choose the changed variable. We change the surface, on purpose.surface
- Choose fixed variables. Keep the ramp, the car and the starting height the same.ramp, car, height
- Write the answer. Accept any answer that names the surface as the changed variable, and one fixed variable such as the ramp, the car or the starting height.
Check. Only the surface changes, so the test is fair. ✓
Taking accurate measurements
Accuracy means how close a measurement is to the true value. Precision means how close repeated measurements are to each other.
To improve accuracy, read the scale at eye level, use a suitable instrument, and repeat each measurement. The mean of the repeats is found by adding them together and dividing by how many there are.
A measuring cylinder shows its scale in millilitres. Read the bottom of the curve of the liquid, which is called the meniscus, with your eyes level with the line.
Tom and Aisha put the results of three trials into a table. Each mean is the total of the three trials divided by three.
| Towel | Trial 1 (mL) | Trial 2 (mL) | Trial 3 (mL) | Mean (mL) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Towel A | 14 | 15 | 13 | 14 |
| Towel B | 9 | 10 | 11 | 10 |
| Towel C | 19 | 18 | 20 | 19 |
Key ideas
- Repeat a measurement, and find the mean of the repeats.
- The mean is the total divided by the number of results.
- Read a measuring cylinder with your eyes level with the liquid.
- A result that is far from the others may be an outlier, and should be checked.
Method. Find the level of the liquid on the scale.
- Find the scale. The scale on the measuring cylinder counts up in millilitres.mL
- Read the level. The liquid level sits at the 34 mL mark, with eyes level with the line.34
- Write the answer. 34 mL
Check. Every small line on this cylinder is 1 mL. ✓
Watch out. Read the bottom of the curve, not the top edge of the liquid.
Method. Add the three trials, then divide by three.
- Add the trials. The total of the three trials is 18 + 19 + 20.18 + 19 + 20 = 57
- Divide by three. There are three trials, so divide the total by 3.57 divided by 3 is 19
- Write the answer. 19 mL
Check. The mean is 19 mL, and the three trials are close together. ✓
Watch out. Divide by the number of trials, which is three here.
Method. Look for the result that is far from the others.
- Compare the results. Three results are 42 or 43, which are close together.close together
- Find the one far away. The result 61 is far from the others, so it is an outlier.61
- Write the answer. 61
Check. Check the 61 cm reading again, because it may be a mistake. ✓
Watch out
Watch out: a single measurement does not show whether a result is reliable. Repeats show whether the readings are close together.
Exam tip
Exam tip. Always say how many repeats you made, and find the mean of the repeats.
Try it (with your teacher, or a grown-up at home). Measure the length of a pencil three times with a ruler. Read the scale at eye level each time. Write the three results and find the mean. Do you get the same number each time? Which result is an outlier, if any?
Exercise 1B Taking accurate measurements
Method. Count the trial columns in the table.
- Read the headings. The table has columns for Trial 1, Trial 2 and Trial 3.three columns
- Write the number. So there were three trials on each towel.3
- Write the answer. 3
Check. Three trials make a mean that is more reliable than one. ✓
Method. Find the level of the liquid.
- Read the level. The liquid is level with the 34 mL mark.34
- Write the reading. The reading is 34 millilitres.mL
- Write the answer. 34 mL
Check. Count up from the 30 mark by 4 small lines. ✓
Method. Add the three results and divide by three.
- Add. The total is 9 + 10 + 11.9 + 10 + 11 = 30
- Divide. Divide the total by the number of results, 3.30 divided by 3 is 10
- Write the answer. 10 mL
Check. Check: 10 + 10 + 10 = 30. ✓
Method. Add the three trials.
- Add the numbers. Put the three trials together.14 + 15 + 13
- Write the total. The total is 42.42
- Write the answer. 42
Check. 42 divided by 3 gives the mean of 14. ✓
Method. Compare the means in the last column.
- Read the means. Towel A has a mean of 14, Towel B has 10, and Towel C has 19.14, 10, 19
- Pick the largest. The largest mean is 19, for Towel C.Towel C
- Write the answer. Towel C
Check. 19 is bigger than 14 and 10. ✓
Method. Think about what repeats tell us.
- Think about the readings. Repeats show how close the readings are to each other.close together
- Think about the mean. A mean of repeats is more reliable than one reading.more reliable
- Write the answer. Accept any answer that says repeats show whether the results are close together, or give a more reliable mean.
Check. One reading can be a mistake; several readings show the pattern. ✓
Method. Add the three readings, then divide by three.
- Add. The total is 17 + 18 + 19.17 + 18 + 19 = 54
- Divide. Divide 54 by 3.54 divided by 3 is 18
- Write the answer. 18 cm
Check. The three readings are 1 cm apart, so the mean is in the middle. ✓
Method. Look for the result that does not fit.
- Compare the three results. 20 and 21 are close together, but 30 is far from them.far away
- Decide which to check. The 30 mL result is an outlier, so it should be checked again.30 mL
- Write the answer. 30 mL, because it is far from the other two results.
Check. Check the reading and the scale again. ✓
Method. Count the small lines after the 20 mark.
- Start at 20. The reading starts at the 20 mL mark.20
- Count on. Three small lines of 1 mL each take it to 23 mL.20 + 3 = 23
- Write the answer. 23 mL
Check. The scale is counted in 1 mL steps. ✓
Method. Think about what one reading can show.
- Think about one reading. One reading cannot show whether it can be repeated.one reading
- Decide. Repeats are needed to show that the result is reliable, so Tom is not right.no
- Write the answer. Accept any answer that says no, because one measurement cannot show how reliable the result is.
Check. Repeat readings show how reliable a result is. ✓
Method. Look at how close the results are to each other.
- Check the means. Both means are 10 mL, so the means are the same.10 mL each
- Compare the spread. Aisha's results are close together, but Tom's results are spread out from 4 to 16.close together
- Write the answer. Aisha
Check. Precision is about how close the repeats are to each other. ✓
Method. Think about chance errors.
- Think about one result. One reading may be too high or too low by chance.chance error
- Think about the mean. Averaging several readings evens out those chance errors.evens out
- Write the answer. Accept any sentence that says a mean from several repeats evens out chance errors, so it is more reliable than one result.
Check. More readings give a fairer picture of the true value. ✓
Recording data in tables and graphs
Scientists record results in tables, so that data is easy to read. They show results in graphs and diagrams.
- A bar chart compares separate groups, such as three towels. Each bar is a group.
- A line graph shows how something changes over time. Points are joined by a line.
Every graph needs a title, labelled axes with units, and a scale that goes up in equal steps. The horizontal axis is the x-axis and the vertical axis is the y-axis.
The table records Mo's bean heights, from the line graph above.
| Week | Height (cm) |
|---|---|
| Week 1 | 4 |
| Week 2 | 7 |
| Week 3 | 11 |
| Week 4 | 16 |
| Week 5 | 20 |
Key ideas
- Use a table to record data clearly.
- Use a bar chart to compare separate groups.
- Use a line graph to show how something changes over time.
- Every graph needs a title, labelled axes, units and an equal scale.
Method. Think about what is being compared.
- Look at the groups. The three towels are separate groups, not steps in time.separate groups
- Choose the graph. A bar chart compares separate groups.bar chart
- Write the answer. bar chart
Check. A line graph would be used for the bean height over weeks. ✓
Method. Subtract the earlier height from the later height.
- Read the heights. Week 3 is 11 cm and week 4 is 16 cm.11 and 16
- Subtract. The growth is 16 minus 11.16 - 11 = 5
- Write the answer. 5 cm
Check. 11 + 5 = 16, so the answer is correct. ✓
Watch out. Growth is the later height minus the earlier height.
Method. Find week 5 in the table.
- Find the row. The row for week 5 gives the height.week 5
- Read the height. The height in week 5 is 20 cm.20
- Write the answer. 20 cm
Check. The line graph reaches 20 cm at week 5. ✓
Watch out
Watch out: a bar chart without units, or a line graph with the axes unlabelled, cannot be read properly. Always write the units.
Exam tip
Exam tip. When you draw a graph, give it a title, label both axes with units, and use equal steps on each scale.
Try it (with your teacher, or a grown-up at home). Measure how tall a plant or a stick is each day for four days, using a ruler and a pencil mark. Write the heights in a table with one row for each day. Then draw a line graph with a title, labelled axes and units.
Exercise 1C Recording data in tables and graphs
Method. Find the shortest bar.
- Compare the bars. Towel B has the shortest bar, at 10 mL.shortest bar
- Read the name. The name under that bar is Towel B.Towel B
- Write the answer. Towel B
Check. Towel C has the tallest bar, at 19 mL. ✓
Method. Read the top of the bar for Towel A.
- Find the bar. The first bar is Towel A.Towel A
- Read its height. The label on top of that bar says 14 mL.14 mL
- Write the answer. 14 mL
Check. This matches the mean in the table in section 1.2. ✓
Method. Find week 2 on the x-axis.
- Find week 2. Week 2 is the second point along the x-axis.week 2
- Read the height. The point at week 2 is at 7 cm on the y-axis.7 cm
- Write the answer. 7 cm
Check. The table also gives 7 cm for week 2. ✓
Method. Subtract week 1 from week 2.
- Read the heights. Week 1 is 4 cm and week 2 is 7 cm.4 and 7
- Subtract. The growth is 7 minus 4.7 - 4 = 3
- Write the answer. 3 cm
Check. 4 + 3 = 7. ✓
Method. Work out the growth for each pair of weeks.
- Week 1 to week 2. The growth is 3 cm.7 - 4 = 3
- Week 3 to week 4. The growth is 5 cm, which is the largest.16 - 11 = 5
- Write the answer. week 3 and week 4
Check. The other growths are 4 cm and 4 cm. ✓
Method. Subtract the week 1 height from the week 5 height.
- Read the heights. Week 1 is 4 cm and week 5 is 20 cm.4 and 20
- Subtract. The total growth is 20 minus 4.20 - 4 = 16
- Write the answer. 16 cm
Check. Adding the weekly growths 3, 4, 5 and 4 also gives 16. ✓
Method. Think about what helps a reader understand a graph.
- List the features. A graph needs a title, labelled axes, units and a scale.title, axes, units, scale
- Write the answer. Accept any two of: a title, labelled axes, units, a scale.
Check. Each feature helps a reader read the graph. ✓
Method. Remember which axis is horizontal.
- Find the horizontal axis. The horizontal axis is the x-axis. The weeks are along it.horizontal
- Name the axis. So the weeks are on the x-axis.x-axis
- Write the answer. x-axis
Check. The height is on the vertical y-axis. ✓
Method. Read the label on the vertical axis.
- Read the label. The label on the vertical axis says mean water absorbed (mL).mL
- Write the unit. So the unit is millilitres.millilitres
- Write the answer. mL
Check. A unit is needed on every scale. ✓
Method. Multiply the height by the value of each centimetre.
- Read the scale. Each 1 cm stands for 2 mL.1 cm = 2 mL
- Multiply. So 7 cm stands for 7 times 2.7 x 2 = 14
- Write the answer. 14 mL
Check. Half of 14 is 7, which is 1 cm for 2 mL. ✓
Method. Check the chart against the list of graph features.
- Check the list. A graph needs a title, labelled axes and units.title, axes, units
- Find the missing feature. The chart is missing its title, so add a title.title
- Write the answer. Accept any one of: a title, the units, labelled axes.
Check. A title tells the reader what the graph shows. ✓
Method. Think about what the bean data shows.
- Think about time. The bean height changes each week, so the data is a change over time.over time
- Think about the graph. A line graph joins the points, so the change is easy to see.joins the points
- Write the answer. Accept any sentence that says a line graph shows how the height changes over time, so the growth is easy to see.
Check. A bar chart suits separate groups, not a change over time. ✓
Method. Find the week where the line rises the most.
- Look at the steepest rise. The steepest rise is between week 3 and week 4.steepest
- Check the growth. The height rises from 11 cm to 16 cm, which is 5 cm.16 - 11 = 5
- Write the answer. week 3 and week 4
Check. A steep line means a big change in a short time. ✓
Method. Think about what units tell the reader.
- Think about the numbers. Numbers without units do not say what they measure.no units
- Decide. So the graph is not complete without units.not complete
- Write the answer. Accept any answer that says no, because the reader cannot tell what the numbers measure without units.
Check. Units tell the reader what each number measures. ✓
Predictions and further tests
A prediction is a sensible guess based on evidence. We use patterns in results to predict what might happen next. A prediction is not proof, so we test it.
A further test checks an idea or repeats a result with a new change. It uses the same method as the first test, with one new changed variable.
Key ideas
- A prediction uses evidence and a pattern in the results.
- A prediction is tested; it is not proof.
- A further test changes one variable, and keeps the rest the same.
- Repeat the test to see whether the result happens again.
Method. Use the pattern from the first test.
- Read the evidence. In the first test Towel C had the largest mean, 19 mL.19 mL
- Make the prediction. If the same pattern holds, Towel C would absorb the most again.Towel C
- Write the answer. Towel C
Check. The prediction should be tested, because the amount of water is different. ✓
Method. Add the growth to the height at the start.
- Start from week 5. The bean is 20 cm in week 5.20 cm
- Add the growth. If it grows 4 cm more, the height is 20 + 4.20 + 4 = 24
- Write the answer. 24 cm
Check. The prediction uses the growth as the pattern, and then the next week will test it. ✓
Method. Find the thing that changes in the further test.
- Read the plan. The further test changes the amount of water.amount of water
- Name the variable. So the changed variable is the amount of water.amount of water
- Write the answer. the amount of water
Check. The towel, and the time, stay the same. ✓
Watch out
Watch out: a prediction is an idea to test. If the results do not match it, the prediction was not supported, and we should say so.
Exam tip
Exam tip. Make a prediction using the evidence, and say which pattern in the results you used.
Try it (with your teacher, or a grown-up at home). Put one plant or one bean seed in a dish of damp cotton wool, and predict how many days it takes to start to sprout. Check every day for a week, and write down what you see. Did the result support your prediction?
Exercise 1D Predictions and further tests
Method. Add the growth to the height at the end of week 5.
- Start at week 5. The bean is 20 cm at the end of week 5.20 cm
- Add the growth. Add 4 cm for week 6.20 + 4 = 24
- Write the answer. 24 cm
Check. This is a prediction, so it can be checked next week. ✓
Method. Look at the first test.
- Read the means. Towel C had the largest mean, 19 mL.19 mL
- Predict. So the prediction is that Towel C absorbs the most again.Towel C
- Write the answer. Towel C
Check. A prediction uses the evidence from the first test. ✓
Method. Think about why we can make a prediction.
- Read the idea. A prediction is a sensible guess based on evidence.evidence
- Write the answer. evidence
Check. Evidence is information from earlier tests or observations. ✓
Method. Keep all the other variables the same.
- Read the test. Only the sunlight changes.sunlight
- Name a fixed variable. The type of bean stays the same, so it is fixed.same bean
- Write the answer. Accept any one of: the type of bean, the amount of water, the pot, the number of days.
Check. Any fixed variable keeps the test fair. ✓
Method. Think about how reliable the mean is.
- Think about repeats. More repeats give a more reliable mean, and 3 is the number used in the first test.three repeats
- Choose. So 3 repeats is a good choice.3
- Write the answer. 3
Check. The first test used three repeats for each towel. ✓
Method. Compare the prediction with the results.
- Read the prediction. Tom predicts that Towel B absorbs more.Towel B more
- Compare. The results show Towel A absorbs more, so the results do not support the prediction.does not support
- Write the answer. no
Check. A prediction can be wrong, and then we say so. ✓
Method. Add two weeks of 5 cm growth to the week 5 height.
- Week 6. The bean is 20 + 5 = 25 cm in week 6.25 cm
- Week 7. The bean is 25 + 5 = 30 cm in week 7.30 cm
- Write the answer. 30 cm
Check. Two weeks of 5 cm each is 10 cm, and 20 + 10 = 30. ✓
Method. Find the thing that changes on purpose.
- Read the plan. The further test changes the size of the towel on purpose.size of the towel
- Write the variable. So the changed variable is the size of the towel.size of the towel
- Write the answer. size of the towel
Check. The water and the type of towel stay the same. ✓
Method. Find what Ruby wants to change.
- Read her idea. Ruby wants to change the temperature of the water.temperature
- Write the variable. So the changed variable is the temperature of the water.temperature of the water
- Write the answer. temperature of the water
Check. The amount of water and the towel must be kept the same. ✓
Method. Think about comparing results.
- Think about the method. If the method changes, the results cannot be compared fairly.cannot be compared
- Think about the change. The same method means only the changed variable can cause a difference.one cause
- Write the answer. Accept any sentence that says using the same method means any difference in the results is caused by the changed variable.
Check. A fair comparison needs the same method each time. ✓
Method. Think about what a prediction is.
- Think about the word. A prediction is a sensible guess that must be tested.guess
- Decide. Only evidence from tests can support an idea, so Ali is not right.no
- Write the answer. Accept any answer that says no, because a prediction is an idea to test, and only evidence from tests can support it.
Check. Test the prediction, then decide whether the evidence supports it. ✓
Method. Think about what plants need.
- Think about water. Plants need water to make their cells and grow.water
- Make the prediction. So without water, the growth would stop or slow down.stop or slow
- Write the answer. Accept any answer that says the growth would stop or slow, because plants need water to grow.
Check. This prediction could be tested by keeping one plant without water. ✓
Conclusions, evidence and trust
A conclusion is a short statement that answers the question of the test, and matches the results. It should say what the results show, and no more.
A causal relationship means that one thing causes a change in another. A fair test with one changed variable helps us show a causal relationship. One set of results does not always prove a cause.
Evidence from tests can support an idea, or refute it, which means show that it is wrong. How much we trust results depends on how many repeats there were, how close they are to each other, and how fair the test was.
Key ideas
- A conclusion must match the results.
- A fair test helps us show that one variable caused a change.
- Evidence can support an idea, or refute it.
- We trust results more when there are repeats, and the repeats are close together.
Method. Use the means to write the conclusion.
- Read the means. Towel A has 14 mL, Towel B has 10 mL and Towel C has 19 mL.14, 10, 19
- Write the conclusion. The largest mean is for Towel C.Towel C
- Write the answer. Towel C
Check. The conclusion matches the data in the table. ✓
Method. Check the idea against the data.
- Read the idea. Tom's idea is about cost, but the test measured the water absorbed.cost
- Decide. The test data says nothing about cost, so it does not support his idea.does not support
- Write the answer. does not support
Check. The data shows absorbency, not price. ✓
Method. Look at how far apart the results are.
- Find the range. The highest result is 11 mL and the lowest is 9 mL, so the range is 2 mL.11 - 9 = 2
- Decide. A range of 2 mL is small, so the results are close together.close together
- Write the answer. yes
Check. Close results make the test more trustworthy. ✓
Watch out
Watch out: a conclusion should not claim more than the data shows. Use the words the results support, and do not add a reason that was not tested.
Exam tip
Exam tip. Write a conclusion that answers the question, matches the data, and uses the numbers from the results.
Try it (with your teacher, or a grown-up at home). Test two kinds of dry kitchen paper, using the same amount of water, the same size of paper and the same time. Repeat three times each. Write a conclusion that matches your results. Say whether the evidence supports the idea that one paper is better, and how sure you are.
Exercise 1E Conclusions, evidence and trust
Method. Find the biggest growth in the table.
- Find the biggest growth. The growth between week 3 and week 4 is 5 cm, which is the largest.5 cm
- Write the conclusion. So the bean grew most between week 3 and week 4.week 3 and week 4
- Write the answer. between week 3 and week 4
Check. Check the other growths: 3, 4 and 4 cm. ✓
Method. Compare the two means.
- Read the means. Towel C has a mean of 19 mL and Towel A has 14 mL.19 and 14
- Decide. Since 19 is more than 14, the answer is yes.yes
- Write the answer. yes
Check. 19 - 14 = 5, so Towel C absorbs 5 mL more on average. ✓
Method. Subtract the lowest result from the highest.
- Find the highest and lowest. The highest is 20 mL and the lowest is 18 mL.20 and 18
- Subtract. The range is 20 minus 18.20 - 18 = 2
- Write the answer. 2
Check. Only 2 mL separates the results, so they are close together. ✓
Method. Think about how trustworthy one set of results is.
- Think about the evidence. One set of results can be a mistake, and it may not be repeated.one set
- Decide. So one set of results does not always prove a cause.no
- Write the answer. no
Check. Repeats and fair tests make a causal claim stronger. ✓
Method. Think about repeats.
- Think about the mean. The mean of three trials evens out chance errors.evens out
- Decide. So three trials are more reliable than one trial.yes
- Write the answer. yes
Check. More trials give a more trustworthy result. ✓
Method. Read the meaning of the words support and refute.
- Read the meanings. Evidence can support an idea, or refute it.support or refute
- Name the word. Evidence that shows an idea is wrong refutes it.refute
- Write the answer. refute
Check. To support is the opposite of to refute. ✓
Method. Read the definition.
- Read the definition. A causal relationship means that one thing causes a change in another.causes a change
- Write the answer. causal relationship
Check. A fair test helps us show a causal relationship. ✓
Method. Plan a fair test of the idea.
- Find the idea. Ruby thinks the sunlight caused the growth.sunlight
- Plan the test. Change only the amount of sunlight, and keep the water, the plant and the pot the same.change only sunlight
- Write the answer. Accept any answer that says to change one thing, such as the amount of sunlight, and keep everything else the same.
Check. Only the changed variable should be different between the two bean plants. ✓
Method. Check the data against the idea.
- Read the data. The data measures the water absorbed, and it does not measure cost.water absorbed
- Decide. So the data does not support the idea about cost.does not support
- Write the answer. does not support
Check. Evidence has to measure the thing in the idea. ✓
Method. Think about trust in results.
- Think about repeats. More repeats make the mean more reliable.more repeats
- Think about fixed variables. Keeping the fixed variables the same stops other causes changing the results.fixed variables
- Write the answer. Accept any answer that says repeat the test more times, or keep the water, the time and the towel size the same.
Check. Either change makes the results easier to trust. ✓
Method. Subtract the smaller mean from the larger mean.
- Read the means. Towel A is 14 mL and Towel B is 10 mL.14 and 10
- Subtract. The difference is 14 minus 10.14 - 10 = 4
- Write the answer. 4 mL
Check. 10 + 4 = 14. ✓
Method. Think about what a conclusion is.
- Think about the question. A conclusion answers the question of the test.the question
- Think about the data. It must say only what the data shows, and no more.only the data
- Write the answer. Accept any sentence that says a conclusion must answer the question of the test and say only what the results show.
Check. A conclusion that claims more than the data is not supported. ✓
Method. Look at how the result changes as the size grows.
- Read the pattern. As the width goes up from 2 cm to 6 cm, the water absorbed goes up from 3 mL to 9 mL.goes up
- Write the conclusion. So the bigger the towel, the more water it absorbed in this test.bigger, more
- Write the answer. Accept any answer that says the bigger the towel, the more water it absorbed in this test.
Check. The conclusion only covers the towels tested. ✓
Method. Look for a variable that was not controlled.
- Find the weakness. If the amount of water was not measured exactly, the test is not fair.not exact
- Find the fix. Measure the water with a measuring cylinder, and use the same amount each time.measuring cylinder
- Write the answer. Accept any answer that names a weakness such as a different amount of water or a different drop time, with a fix such as keeping it the same.
Check. An evaluation names a weakness and a fix. ✓
Chapter summary
| Skill | Method |
|---|---|
| Fair tests | Change only one variable on purpose. Keep the fixed variables the same. Measure the measured variable. |
| Accuracy and precision | Repeat measurements and take the mean. Close repeats are precise. Read scales carefully. |
| Tables and graphs | Record results in a table. Use bar charts for groups and line graphs for change over time. Label axes with units. |
| Predictions | Use the pattern in the evidence to predict. Test the prediction with a further test. |
| Conclusions and evidence | Write a conclusion that matches the data. Evidence can support or refute an idea. Trust results with repeats. |
Can you…?
- I can name the changed, measured and fixed variables in a fair test
- I can plan a fair test that changes only one variable
- I can take repeat readings, find the mean, and spot an outlier
- I can read a measuring cylinder to the nearest millilitre
- I can choose a bar chart or a line graph, and label it fully
- I can make a prediction from results, and say what a further test would check
- I can write a conclusion that matches the data, and say whether evidence supports an idea
Key terms
- fair test
- a test in which only one variable is changed and the others are kept the same
- changed variable
- the one thing we change on purpose in a test
- measured variable
- the thing we measure to get the results
- fixed variables
- the things that are kept the same in a fair test
- accuracy
- how close a measurement is to the true value
- precision
- how close repeated measurements are to each other
- mean
- the total of several results divided by the number of results
- outlier
- a result that is far from the others and should be checked
- prediction
- a sensible guess, based on evidence, about what will happen
- evidence
- information from tests or observations that can support or refute an idea
- causal relationship
- when one thing causes a change in another
- conclusion
- a short statement that answers the question of a test, and matches the results
Exercise 1Z Check-up
Method. Read the test again.
- Find the changed variable. We change the type of towel on purpose.type of towel
- Find the measured variable. We measure the water absorbed to get the results.water absorbed
- Write the answer. type of towel; water absorbed
Check. These are the two variables in the test. ✓
Method. Remember the rule.
- Read the rule. A fair test changes only one variable.one
- Write the answer. 1
Check. Other variables are fixed. ✓
Method. Add and divide by three.
- Add. The total is 19 + 18 + 20.57
- Divide. Divide 57 by 3.57 divided by 3 is 19
- Write the answer. 19
Check. Three trials, so divide by 3. ✓
Method. Read the level on the scale.
- Find the mark. The liquid is level with the 40 mL mark.40
- Write the reading. The reading is 40 mL.mL
- Write the answer. 40 mL
Check. Read the bottom of the curve. ✓
Method. Think about separate groups.
- Read the task. The three towels are separate groups.separate groups
- Choose. A bar chart compares separate groups.bar chart
- Write the answer. bar chart
Check. A line graph shows change over time. ✓
Method. Subtract.
- Subtract the earlier height from the later height. The growth is 16 minus 11.16 - 11 = 5
- Write the answer. 5 cm
Check. 11 + 5 = 16. ✓
Method. Think about whether it has been measured yet.
- Read the sentence. Week 6 has not happened yet, so the height is a guess based on a pattern.not yet
- Decide. A guess based on a pattern is a prediction.prediction
- Write the answer. prediction
Check. A prediction is tested later by measuring. ✓
Method. Think about what a prediction is.
- Think about the guess. A prediction is based on a pattern, and may be wrong.may be wrong
- Think about the test. A further test shows whether the evidence supports the prediction.supports
- Write the answer. Accept any sentence that says a prediction is only a guess until it is tested, and the test shows whether it is supported.
Check. Testing is how science checks an idea. ✓
Method. Find the result that does not fit the others.
- Compare. Three results are 42 or 43.42, 43
- Find the outlier. The result 61 is far away from the others.61
- Write the answer. 61
Check. Check this reading again. ✓
Method. Think about repeats.
- Think about the spread. Repeats show how close the results are to each other.close together
- Think about the mean. A mean of repeats is more reliable than one reading.more reliable
- Write the answer. Accept any sentence that says repeats show how close the results are, and a mean of repeats is more reliable than one result.
Check. Repeats make the result more trustworthy. ✓
Total 16 marks. Allow about 16 minutes.
Exercise 1X Practice test questions
Method. Find the thing that changes on purpose.
- Read the test. The class changes the towel, and keeps the water and the size the same.type of towel
- Write the answer. type of towel
Check. The water and the size are the fixed variables. ✓
Method. Check the number of changes.
- Count the changes. Only the amount of water changes; the towel is the same.only water
- Write the reason. With one changed variable, the test is a fair test of the water.one variable
- Write the answer. Accept any answer that says only one variable, the amount of water, changes.
Check. Only one variable changes in a fair test. ✓
Method. Add the three readings, then divide by three.
- Add. The total is 120 + 121 + 122.363
- Divide. Divide 363 by 3.363 divided by 3 is 121
- Write the answer. 121 cm
Check. The three readings are close together. ✓
Method. Work out the growth for each pair of weeks.
- Week 1 to week 2. The growth is 6 minus 3.3 cm
- Week 2 to week 3. The growth is 10 minus 6, which is 4 cm, the largest so far.4 cm
- Week 3 to week 4. The growth is 13 minus 10, which is 3 cm.3 cm
- Write the answer. week 2 and week 3
Check. Growth of 3, 4 and 3 cm. ✓
Method. Multiply the height by the value of one centimetre.
- Read the scale. Each 1 cm stands for 5 mL.1 cm = 5 mL
- Multiply. So 6 cm stands for 6 times 5.6 x 5 = 30
- Write the answer. 30 mL
Check. Check: 30 divided by 5 is 6 cm. ✓
Method. Think about the number of tests.
- Count the tests. Each towel was tested only once.once
- Explain the weakness. One result can be a chance result, so the evidence is weak.chance
- Write the answer. Accept any sentence that says the test was done only once, so the result may be a chance result.
Check. Repeats make the evidence stronger. ✓
Method. Add 3 cm for each of the four weeks.
- Find the total growth. Four weeks of 3 cm is 4 times 3.4 x 3 = 12
- Add to the start. The height is 10 plus the growth of 12.10 + 12 = 22
- Write the answer. 22 cm
Check. This is a prediction, and it is tested by measuring. ✓
Method. Find the result that does not fit.
- Compare the results. Four results are 40 or 41 cm, which are close together.40, 41
- Find the outlier. The result 58 cm is far from the others.58 cm
- Write the answer. 58 cm
Check. The outlier should be checked, and it may be a mistake. ✓
Method. Count the changed variables.
- Count. The student changes two variables: the surface and the ramp height.two
- Explain. If the car goes further, we cannot tell which change caused it.which change
- Write the answer. Accept any answer that says two variables change, so the cause of any difference cannot be known.
Check. A fair test changes only one variable. ✓
Method. Find the largest mean.
- Read the means. The means are 14, 10 and 19 mL.19 is the largest
- Write the conclusion. So Towel C absorbed the most water on average.Towel C
- Write the answer. Towel C
Check. 19 mL is more than 14 mL and 10 mL. ✓