Working scientifically: planning and reporting
By the end of this chapter you will be able to
- Name the independent variable, the dependent variable and the control variables in a test
- Choose an instrument with a fine enough scale, take repeat readings and find the mean
- Record results in a table, and draw a bar chart, a line graph or a scatter graph that can be read correctly
- Use a pattern in results to make a prediction, and plan a further test
- Write a conclusion that matches the results, and say how much a result can be trusted
- Say whether evidence supports or refutes an idea
You should already know
- Fair tests, and changing only one thing at a time (Year 3 Science, Chapter 1)
- Measuring length, and recording results in a table (Year 4 Maths and Science)
Where this leads
- Forces, gravity and resistance, where fair tests are used again (Year 5 Science, Chapters 9 and 10)
- Solutions and separating mixtures, with careful measurements (Year 5 Science, Chapter 6)
National Curriculum for England, Key Stage 2 science, Year 5. Content: WS1 plan different types of scientific enquiries to answer questions, including recognising and controlling variables, WS2 take measurements with increasing accuracy and precision, taking repeat readings when appropriate, WS3 record data and results of increasing complexity using diagrams, labels, classification keys, tables, scatter graphs, bar and line graphs, WS4 use test results to make predictions and to set up further comparative and fair tests, WS5 report and present findings, including conclusions, causal relationships and degree of trust in results, WS6 identify scientific evidence used to support or refute ideas or arguments.
Exercise P Do you remember?
Method. Think about what makes a test fair.
- Read the idea. In a fair test, only one thing is changed.one thing changed
- Name it. This kind of test is called a fair test.fair test
- Write the answer. fair test
Check. Changing one thing at a time is the key idea of a fair test. ✓
Method. Think about the unit printed on the ruler.
- Read the ruler. A ruler marked in centimetres has the unit cm.cm
- Name the unit. So the length is measured in centimetres.cm
- Write the answer. cm
Check. Centimetres are written as cm. ✓
Method. Think about how results are organised.
- Think about the layout. Results are set out in rows and columns so they are easy to read.rows and columns
- Name it. A layout of rows and columns is called a table.table
- Write the answer. table
Check. Tables keep results in order. ✓
Method. Think about a guess made before testing.
- Read the meaning. A guess written before a test, based on what you know, is a prediction.guess before a test
- Name it. The word is prediction.prediction
- Write the answer. prediction
Check. A prediction is tested, and it may turn out to be right or wrong. ✓
Method. Think about what changes as a result of the test.
- Think about the measurement. The thing you measure depends on the change you make.depends
- Name it. The variable you measure is the dependent variable.dependent
- Write the answer. dependent
Check. The independent variable is the one you change on purpose. ✓
Planning a fair test
A scientific enquiry starts with a question, and a plan that can answer it. Scientists can plan different types of enquiry:
- a fair test, where only one thing is changed and everything else is kept the same;
- pattern seeking, where something is observed and measured over time, such as the number of birds in a garden each week;
- classifying, where things are sorted into groups using their features;
- research, where information is found in books or from reliable sources.
In a fair test there are three kinds of variable. A variable is a thing that can change.
- The independent variable is the one you change on purpose.
- The dependent variable is the one you measure. It depends on the change you make.
- Control variables are the things you keep the same.
Key ideas
- A fair test changes only one thing: the independent variable.
- The dependent variable is measured. It is the result of the test.
- Control variables are kept the same, so the test is fair.
- Other types of enquiry include pattern seeking, classifying and research.
Method. Read the labels in the diagram.
- Find the label for the same things. The labels say the car, surface and release point are kept the same.Kept the same: car, surface
- Choose the one that is kept the same. The surface is kept the same. The ramp height is the thing that is changed.the surface
- Write the answer. the surface
Check. Only the ramp height is changed on purpose. ✓
Watch out. The changed variable is never a control variable.
Method. Find the variable that is measured.
- Find the change on purpose. Mo changes the mass of the car on purpose, so mass is the independent variable.mass
- Find the measurement. Mo measures how long the car takes to roll, so time taken is the dependent variable.time taken
- Write the answer. time taken
Check. The time depends on the mass Mo chose. ✓
Method. Think about what else could change the time.
- Think about the test. The ramp, the surface and the release point could all change the time.ramp, surface, release
- Choose one to keep the same. Any one of these must stay the same for the test to be fair.Accept any one
- Write the answer. Accept any one of: the ramp height, the surface, the release point.
Check. Keep the control variables the same. ✓
Watch out
Watch out: a variable that you keep the same is a control variable. It is not the dependent variable, because you do not measure it.
Try it (with your teacher or a grown-up). Put a book under one end of a ramp (a board or a tray will do). Roll a toy car from the same starting point, three times with one book, and three times with two books. Keep the car, the surface and the starting point the same. Which variable did you change on purpose?
Exam tip
Grown-up tip. Ask: “What did you change on purpose? What did you measure? What did you keep the same?” Your child should answer with the words independent, dependent and control.
Exercise 1A Planning a fair test
Method. Find the variable that is changed on purpose.
- Read the test. Ruby changes the height of the ramp on purpose.height of the ramp
- Name the variable. The variable that is changed on purpose is the independent variable.the height of the ramp
- Write the answer. the height of the ramp
Check. The height of the ramp is the one thing that changes. ✓
Method. Find the thing that is measured.
- Read the test. Ruby measures how far the car rolls.how far the car rolls
- Name the variable. That is the dependent variable: the distance rolled.distance rolled
- Write the answer. distance rolled
Check. The distance depends on the ramp height. ✓
Method. Read the definition.
- Read the definition. The variable you change on purpose is called the independent variable.independent
- Fill the gap. So the missing word is independent.independent
- Write the answer. independent
Check. Independent means you are free to choose it. ✓
Method. Read the definition.
- Read the definition. The variable you measure depends on the change you make, so it is the dependent variable.dependent
- Fill the gap. So the missing word is dependent.dependent
- Write the answer. dependent
Check. It depends on the independent variable. ✓
Method. Think about what must stay the same.
- Think about the test. The car, the surface and the release point must stay the same.same car
- Write one. Any one of these is a correct control variable.one control variable
- Write the answer. Accept any one of: the same car, the same surface, the same release point.
Check. Keeping the control variables the same makes the test fair. ✓
Method. Think about how many things are changed.
- Count the changes. Tom changes three things at once: the car, the ramp and the surface.three things
- Decide. A fair test changes only one thing, so this is not a fair test.no
- Write the answer. no
Check. If three things change, you cannot tell which one made the difference. ✓
Method. Think about what Priya does over time.
- Read what she does. Priya observes and counts the birds each day, to see how the number changes over time.over time
- Name the type of enquiry. Observing and measuring something over time is pattern seeking.pattern seeking
- Write the answer. pattern seeking
Check. Pattern seeking looks for changes over time, not a test with one change. ✓
Method. Count the things that are changed.
- Read the test. Mo changes only the height of the ramp.only the height
- Count. Only one variable is changed on purpose, so the number is 1.1
- Write the answer. 1
Check. Three heights are tested, but the thing changed is always the same kind of variable: height. ✓
Method. Find the variable that Aisha changes on purpose.
- Read the test. Aisha changes the number of paper clips on purpose.number of paper clips
- Name it. The variable changed on purpose is the independent variable.number of paper clips
- Write the answer. number of paper clips
Check. The paper clips are added on purpose, so they are the independent variable. ✓
Method. Find what is measured.
- Read the test. Aisha measures how far the paper plane flies.how far it flies
- Name it. The thing measured is the dependent variable: the distance flown.distance flown
- Write the answer. distance flown
Check. The distance depends on the number of paper clips. ✓
Method. Think about what is kept the same.
- Think about the throw. Aisha keeps the throw the same, so it is not changed.kept the same
- Decide. A variable that is kept the same is a control variable, so the answer is yes.yes
- Write the answer. yes
Check. The throw is kept the same, so it is one of the control variables. ✓
Method. Think about the fair test.
- Think about the change. Only the ramp height should change on purpose.only the height
- Write the reason. If the release point changed, the distance could change for that reason too.could change
- Write the answer. Accept any sentence that says the release point must stay the same, so that only the ramp height changes and the test is fair.
Check. Keeping the release point the same keeps the test fair. ✓
Measuring with increasing accuracy
Precision means how finely a measurement can be read. A ruler marked in millimetres is more precise than a ruler marked in centimetres, because its smallest step is smaller.
Accuracy means how close a measurement is to the true value.
To improve a measurement, use an instrument with a finer scale, and take repeat readings. Add the readings together and divide by how many there are. This is the mean. If one result is very different from the others, it is anomalous. Check it, and if there is a clear reason it was wrong, leave it out of the mean.
| Instrument | Smallest step on the scale |
|---|---|
| Ruler marked in cm | 1 cm |
| Ruler marked in mm | 1 mm |
| Measuring cylinder marked every 10 ml | 10 ml |
| Measuring cylinder marked every 1 ml | 1 ml |
Key ideas
- Precision is how finely a measurement can be read.
- Accuracy is how close a measurement is to the true value.
- Repeat readings are added together and divided by the number of readings to find the mean.
- An anomalous result is very different from the others, and can be left out of the mean if there is a clear reason.
Method. Add the three trials, then divide by three.
- Add the trials. The three trials add together to make 129 cm.41 + 45 + 43 = 129
- Divide by the number of trials. There are three trials, so divide 129 by 3.129 divided by 3 is 43
- Write the answer. 43
Check. Check: 43 + 43 + 43 = 129. ✓
Watch out. Divide by the number of readings, which is three here.
Method. Compare the smallest steps.
- Read the two rulers. One ruler has steps of 1 cm, and the other has steps of 1 mm.1 cm and 1 mm
- Choose the finer scale. A smaller step means the ruler can be read more precisely.smaller step
- Write the answer. mm
Check. There are 10 millimetres in every centimetre. ✓
Method. Take out the anomalous result, then find the mean of the rest.
- Leave out the anomaly. The 73 cm result is very different from the others, so it is left out. The other three are 44, 46 and 45.44, 46, 45
- Find the mean. The three add to 135 cm, and 135 divided by 3 is 45.135 divided by 3 is 45
- Write the answer. 45
Check. Check: 45 + 45 + 45 = 135. ✓
Watch out. Divide by 3, not 4, because the anomalous result has been left out.
Watch out
Watch out: a repeat reading is not the same as a copy. Measure again each time, and then find the mean. If you leave out a result, divide by the number of results that are left.
Try it (with your teacher or a grown-up). Measure the same book three times with a ruler, and write each length down. Then find the mean. Did you get the same answer each time? Measure once more with a ruler that has a finer scale, if you have one, and compare the two.
Exam tip
Grown-up tip. Ask: “Which measurement did you trust most, and why?” Let your child add the readings and divide by the number of readings.
Exercise 1B Measuring with increasing accuracy
Method. Look at the smallest step on each scale.
- Compare the steps. A ruler marked in millimetres has smaller steps than a ruler marked in centimetres.smaller steps
- Write the unit. The smallest step is 1 mm.mm
- Write the answer. mm
Check. There are 10 mm in 1 cm, so mm gives a finer reading. ✓
Method. Find the cylinder with the smaller step.
- Read the table. One cylinder is marked every 10 ml, and the other is marked every 1 ml.10 ml and 1 ml
- Choose the finer scale. The smaller step, 1 ml, is the more precise cylinder.1 ml
- Write the answer. 1 ml
Check. A step of 1 ml is ten times finer than a step of 10 ml. ✓
Method. Add the trials and divide by three.
- Add the trials. The trials add to 129 cm.41 + 45 + 43 = 129
- Divide by three. Divide 129 by 3 to find the mean.129 divided by 3 is 43
- Write the answer. 43
Check. Check: 43 + 43 + 43 = 129. ✓
Method. Add the three results, then divide by three.
- Add them. The three results add to 243 mm.80 + 82 + 81 = 243
- Divide. Divide 243 by 3 to get the mean.243 divided by 3 is 81
- Write the answer. 81
Check. Check: 81 + 81 + 81 = 243. ✓
Method. Add the three numbers, then divide by three.
- Add them. The three numbers add to 36.10 + 12 + 14 = 36
- Divide. Divide 36 by 3 to find the mean.36 divided by 3 is 12
- Write the answer. 12
Check. The mean of 10, 12 and 14 is in the middle, which is 12. ✓
Method. Find the result that is very different from the others.
- Look at the readings. Three readings are close to 45 cm, but 73 cm is much bigger.much bigger
- Name the anomaly. So the anomalous result is 73 cm.73
- Write the answer. 73
Check. Check the anomaly before leaving it out. ✓
Method. Leave out the anomaly, then find the mean of the rest.
- Leave out the anomaly. Without 73 cm, the readings are 44, 46 and 45.44, 46, 45
- Find the mean. They add to 135, and 135 divided by 3 is 45.135 divided by 3 is 45
- Write the answer. 45
Check. Check: 45 + 45 + 45 = 135. ✓
Method. Find the result that is very different from the others.
- Compare the heights. Three of the heights are close to 30 cm, but 52 cm is far bigger.far bigger
- Name the anomaly. So the anomalous result is 52 cm.52
- Write the answer. 52
Check. Priya should check this result before she leaves it out. ✓
Method. Read the two definitions in section 1.2.
- Read the definitions. Accuracy is how close a measurement is to the true value.close to the true value
- Choose the word. So the word is accurate.accurate
- Write the answer. accurate
Check. Precise means how finely a result can be read. ✓
Method. Think about what repeat readings are used for.
- Think about repeats. Repeat readings are added together and divided by how many there are.added and divided
- Fill the gap. The number found this way is the mean.mean
- Write the answer. mean
Check. Repeats also show whether the readings agree with each other. ✓
Method. Think about what a single reading can miss.
- Think about one reading. One reading can be affected by one mistake or by chance.one mistake
- Write the reason. Several readings make a single mistake less important.less important
- Write the answer. Accept any sentence that says repeat readings reduce the effect of one mistake or chance, so the result can be trusted more.
Check. Repeat readings make the result more reliable. ✓
Recording data and drawing graphs
Results are recorded in a table with a heading for each column, and the units in the heading, such as cm or ml.
Choose the right kind of graph for your data:
- a bar chart for separate groups, such as four materials;
- a line graph for a measurement that changes over time, with the points joined;
- a scatter graph for two measured variables, with the points not joined, to see a pattern.
A classification key sorts things into groups by asking questions. Each question has two answers, yes or no, and each answer leads to the next question or to a group.
| Ramp height (cm) | Distance rolled (cm) |
|---|---|
| 2 | 23 |
| 4 | 31 |
| 6 | 40 |
| 8 | 47 |
| 10 | 55 |
| 12 | 63 |
| Material | Water soaked up in 1 minute (ml) |
|---|---|
| Kitchen roll | 18 |
| Tissue | 12 |
| Newspaper | 9 |
| Cardboard | 4 |
| Time (minutes) | Temperature (°C) |
|---|---|
| 0 | 50 |
| 5 | 44 |
| 10 | 39 |
| 15 | 35 |
| 20 | 32 |
Key ideas
- A table has a heading for each column, with units.
- A bar chart shows separate groups. A line graph shows change over time, with the points joined.
- A scatter graph shows two measured variables, with the points not joined.
- Every axis of a graph needs a label, with its unit.
- A classification key uses yes or no questions to sort things into groups.
Method. Think about what kind of data this is.
- Look at the data. Each material is a separate group, and the amount is measured for each one.separate groups
- Choose the graph. Separate groups are shown best on a bar chart.bar chart
- Write the answer. bar chart
Check. A bar chart compares groups side by side. ✓
Method. Find 12 cm on the ramp height axis, then read the point above it.
- Find the height. Look along the horizontal axis to 12 cm.12 cm
- Read the distance. The point above 12 cm is at 63 on the distance axis.63 cm
- Write the answer. 63
Check. The table says 63 cm for a 12 cm ramp. ✓
Method. Follow the key from the first question.
- Read the first question. The question asks: does it have feathers?feathers
- Follow the answer. The answer is yes, so the key sends the animal to the bird group.yes, so bird
- Write the answer. bird
Check. Each yes or no answer leads to the next step in the key. ✓
Watch out
Watch out: join the points on a line graph, but not on a scatter graph. A scatter graph shows a pattern, not a line of change over time.
Try it (with your teacher or a grown-up). Choose four socks, or four small pieces of fabric, from a drawer. Use a table to record how many are cotton, and how many are wool. Then draw a bar chart with a title and labelled axes. Check that the scale on your chart goes up in equal steps.
Exam tip
Grown-up tip. Ask: “What does each axis show? What units did you use?” Let your child choose the graph and say why.
Exercise 1C Recording data and drawing graphs
Method. Read the description of each kind of graph.
- Read the descriptions. A scatter graph shows two measured variables, and its points are not joined.not joined
- Name the graph. So the answer is a scatter graph.scatter graph
- Write the answer. scatter graph
Check. A scatter graph is used to look for a pattern. ✓
Method. Think about separate groups.
- Think about the groups. Each material is its own group.separate groups
- Name the graph. Separate groups are compared on a bar chart.bar chart
- Write the answer. bar chart
Check. Each bar is one group. ✓
Method. Think about change over time.
- Think about time. A measurement that changes over time is plotted in order of time.over time
- Name the graph. Points joined in order of time make a line graph.line graph
- Write the answer. line graph
Check. The points of a line graph are joined in time order. ✓
Method. Find 6 cm on the ramp height axis, then read the distance.
- Find the height. Follow the horizontal axis to 6 cm.6 cm
- Read the distance. The point above 6 cm is at 40 on the distance axis.40 cm
- Write the answer. 40
Check. The table says 40 cm for a 6 cm ramp. ✓
Method. Find 55 on the distance axis, then read the height below it.
- Find the distance. Follow the vertical axis to 55 cm.55 cm
- Read the height. The point at 55 cm is above 10 cm on the height axis.10 cm
- Write the answer. 10
Check. The point for 10 cm is at 55 cm. ✓
Method. Find the bar for kitchen roll and read its height.
- Find the bar. The first bar is for kitchen roll.kitchen roll
- Read the label. The label on that bar says 18 ml.18 ml
- Write the answer. 18
Check. The bar for kitchen roll is the tallest. ✓
Method. Subtract the smaller amount from the larger amount.
- Read the two bars. Kitchen roll is 18 ml, and cardboard is 4 ml.18 and 4
- Subtract. The difference is 18 minus 4, which is 14.18 - 4 = 14
- Write the answer. 14
Check. Check: 4 + 14 = 18. ✓
Method. Find 10 minutes on the time axis, then read the point above it.
- Find the time. Follow the time axis to 10 minutes.10 minutes
- Read the temperature. The point above 10 minutes is at 39 degrees Celsius.39
- Write the answer. 39
Check. The temperature table says 39 degrees at 10 minutes. ✓
Method. Subtract the last temperature from the first.
- Read the two points. At 0 minutes the water is 50 degrees, and at 20 minutes it is 32 degrees.50 and 32
- Subtract. The fall is 50 minus 32, which is 18 degrees.50 - 32 = 18
- Write the answer. 18
Check. Check: 32 + 18 = 50. ✓
Method. Think about a classification key.
- Think about each question. Each question in a key has two answers.two answers
- Name the answers. The two answers are yes and no.yes and no
- Write the answer. yes and no
Check. Each answer leads to the next question, or to a group. ✓
Method. Think about what a line graph shows.
- Think about the graph. A line graph shows change over time, so the points are joined in time order.joined in time order
- Decide. So the answer is yes.yes
- Write the answer. yes
Check. A scatter graph would not join its points. ✓
Method. Think about someone reading your graph.
- Think about the reader. Someone who has not seen the test needs to know what is measured.what is measured
- Write the reason. The unit tells them how big each value is.how big
- Write the answer. Accept any sentence that says the labels show what each axis measures, and the unit it is measured in, so the graph can be read correctly.
Check. Labels and units make a graph readable. ✓
Predicting and planning a further test
A prediction is a sensible guess based on the evidence you already have. Look for the pattern in the results. A prediction for a value between two measured values is usually more reliable than one far outside the values tested.
Once you have results, you can plan a further test. A further comparative test changes one thing in a new way, such as the surface. The results of one test help you decide what to test next.
Key ideas
- A prediction is based on the evidence from earlier tests.
- A prediction between two measured values is usually more reliable than one far outside them.
- A test is needed to check a prediction.
- A further test changes only one thing, so that its result is fair.
Method. Read the two distances from the graph.
- Read the distances. The car rolled 55 cm from 10 cm, and 47 cm from 8 cm.55 and 47
- Subtract. The difference is 55 minus 47, which is 8.55 - 47 = 8
- Write the answer. 8
Check. Check: 47 + 8 = 55. ✓
Watch out. Subtract the smaller distance from the larger one.
Method. Find the thing that is measured.
- Find the change. Priya changes the surface on purpose.surface
- Find the measurement. She measures how far the car rolls on each surface.distance rolled
- Write the answer. distance rolled
Check. The distance depends on the surface Priya chooses. ✓
Method. Compare the prediction with the results.
- Read the two results. The 12 cm ramp gave 63 cm, and the 10 cm ramp gave 55 cm.63 and 55
- Compare them. Ruby predicted the 12 cm ramp would go further, and 63 is more than 55.further
- Write the answer. yes
Check. The result matches the prediction. ✓
Watch out
Watch out: a prediction is not a fact. Test it, and change the prediction if the evidence does not agree.
Try it (with your teacher or a grown-up). Roll a toy car down a ramp made from one book, and measure how far it rolls. Then predict how far it will roll from a ramp of two books. Test your prediction three times, and find the mean. Was your prediction close?
Exam tip
Grown-up tip. Ask: “What did you predict? What pattern made you think that?” Let your child compare the prediction with the mean of the results.
Exercise 1D Predicting and planning a further test
Method. Think about where 7 cm sits between 6 cm and 8 cm.
- Find the position. 7 cm lies between 6 cm and 8 cm.between 6 and 8
- Check the distances. The distances for those heights are 40 cm and 47 cm, so the answer for 7 cm lies between them.between 40 and 47
- Write the answer. yes
Check. A prediction for a value between two results should lie between their values. ✓
Method. Think about what a prediction is built from.
- Think about the basis. A prediction is a sensible guess based on what we have already measured.already measured
- Fill the gap. What we have already measured is the evidence.evidence
- Write the answer. evidence
Check. Evidence is the results and observations we already have. ✓
Method. Compare 14 cm with the heights that were tested.
- Read the range. The heights tested were from 2 cm to 12 cm.2 cm to 12 cm
- Compare. 14 cm is bigger than 12 cm, so it is outside the range.outside
- Write the answer. outside
Check. A prediction outside the range tested is less reliable. ✓
Method. Think about the evidence for each kind of prediction.
- Think about inside values. A value inside the tested range is supported by the results around it.supported
- Decide. So a prediction inside the range is usually more reliable.yes
- Write the answer. yes
Check. Outside the range there is no evidence to support the pattern. ✓
Method. Find the variable that Mo changes on purpose.
- Read the plan. Mo wants to test whether the mass of the car changes the distance.mass of the car
- Name the variable. The variable changed on purpose is the mass of the car.the mass of the car
- Write the answer. the mass of the car
Check. The mass is the only thing that changes in a fair test of mass. ✓
Method. Think about a rough surface.
- Think about the towel. A towel is rough, so it slows the car more.rough
- Make the prediction. So the car should roll less far on the towel.towel
- Write the answer. towel
Check. Aisha can test this prediction with a fair test. ✓
Method. Count the things that change.
- Count the changes. Two things change: the ramp height and the colour of the car.two things
- Decide. Only one thing should change in a fair test, so the answer is no.no
- Write the answer. no
Check. Ali should change one thing only. ✓
Method. Think about the surface.
- Think about the tray. A smooth tray is less rough than carpet.less rough
- Write the reason. Less friction means the car keeps moving for longer.less friction
- Write the answer. Accept any reason that says a smooth surface makes less friction, so the car rolls further.
Check. Test the prediction with a fair test. ✓
Method. Compare the prediction with the measurement.
- Find the difference. The difference between 46 cm and 45 cm is only 1 cm.1 cm
- Decide. A difference of 1 cm is close, so the answer is yes.yes
- Write the answer. yes
Check. Close predictions show the pattern was a good guide. ✓
Method. Use the pattern from the graph.
- Use the pattern. The graph shows that a higher ramp gives a longer distance.higher ramp
- Write the prediction. So a higher ramp should make the car roll a longer distance.longer distance
- Write the answer. Accept any prediction that says a higher ramp makes the car roll a longer distance.
Check. Test your prediction three times, and find the mean. ✓
Method. Think about the range of the evidence.
- Read the range. The heights tested were 2 cm to 12 cm.2 cm to 12 cm
- Decide. 14 cm is outside that range, so the prediction is less reliable.outside the range
- Write the answer. No. Accept any reason that says 14 cm is outside the heights tested, so the prediction is less reliable.
Check. Predictions outside the tested range need checking with a further test. ✓
Method. Think about what a test does.
- Think about the test. A test gathers new evidence about the prediction.new evidence
- Write the reason. The result shows whether the prediction matches the evidence.matches the evidence
- Write the answer. Accept any sentence that says a test shows whether the evidence matches the prediction.
Check. A prediction is a guess until it is tested. ✓
Reporting findings, evidence and trust
A report says what you did, what you found and what you conclude. The conclusion must match the results, and it should say no more than the evidence shows.
A causal relationship means that one thing causes a change in another. To show a cause, the test must be fair, so that only one thing changed. A pattern in results alone does not prove a cause.
The degree of trust in a result depends on how it was obtained. Results are more trusted when the test was fair, the measurements were precise, and the readings were repeated and agree.
Evidence can support an idea, when it agrees with it, or refute it, when it does not.
The steps of a scientific enquiry go round in a loop: an idea leads to a test, the test gives evidence, and the evidence supports or refutes the idea.
Key ideas
- A conclusion must match the results.
- A causal relationship is when one thing causes a change in another, shown by a fair test.
- Repeat readings, precise measurements and a fair test all increase the degree of trust.
- Evidence supports an idea when it agrees with the idea, and refutes it when it does not.
Method. Check the direction of the pattern.
- Look at the points. The distance rises as the ramp height rises, for every height tested.rises
- Decide. So the evidence supports the conclusion.supports
- Write the answer. yes
Check. The evidence agrees with the conclusion. ✓
Method. Think about repeat readings.
- Think about the repeats. Repeating a test shows whether the results agree.agree
- Decide. Results that agree are more trusted, so the answer is yes.yes
- Write the answer. yes
Check. Repeating the test helps show the result is reliable. ✓
Method. Compare the evidence with the idea.
- Read the results. The results show no change in the distance.no change
- Compare. The evidence does not agree with the idea, so it refutes it.does not agree
- Write the answer. refute
Check. Evidence that does not agree with an idea refutes it. ✓
Watch out
Watch out: a pattern in results does not prove a cause unless the test was fair. If two things changed at once, you cannot tell which one caused the result.
Try it (with your teacher or a grown-up). Repeat the book-ramp test from section 1.1 three times. Write a short report with three parts: what you did, what you found, and your conclusion. Say whether your conclusion matches your results, and give one reason why you can trust them.
Exam tip
Grown-up tip. Ask: “Does your conclusion match your results? How do you know the test was fair?” Let your child read the report aloud.
Exercise 1E Reporting findings, evidence and trust
Method. Think about the last part of a report.
- Read the parts. A report says what was done, what was found, and what was concluded.concluded
- Name the part. The part that says what the results show is the conclusion.conclusion
- Write the answer. conclusion
Check. The conclusion comes from the results. ✓
Method. Think about what a conclusion is for.
- Think about the conclusion. A conclusion says what the results show.what the results show
- Decide. So it must match the results, and the answer is yes.yes
- Write the answer. yes
Check. A conclusion that goes beyond the results is not supported. ✓
Method. Think about what repeats show.
- Think about repeats. Repeats show whether the results agree.agree
- Choose. Repeating the test makes the result more trusted.repeating
- Write the answer. repeating
Check. A single result can be a mistake or a chance result. ✓
Method. Read the meaning of a causal relationship.
- Read the meaning. A causal relationship is when one thing makes another thing change.makes another change
- Fill the gap. So the missing word is causes.causes
- Write the answer. causes
Check. A fair test is needed to show a cause. ✓
Method. Think about the two changes.
- Count the changes. Two things changed at once, so the test cannot show which one caused the change.two things
- Decide. So the answer is no.no
- Write the answer. no
Check. A fair test changes one thing only. ✓
Method. Think about what agreement means.
- Think about the agreement. Evidence that agrees with an idea helps to show it is likely to be true.agrees
- Choose the word. So the evidence supports the idea.support
- Write the answer. support
Check. Support means the evidence agrees. ✓
Method. Think about what disagreement means.
- Think about the disagreement. Evidence that does not agree with an idea goes against it.goes against
- Choose the word. So the evidence refutes the idea.refute
- Write the answer. refute
Check. Refute means the evidence goes against the idea. ✓
Method. Read the boxes in order, from left to right.
- Find the first box. The first box is Idea, and the second is Fair test.Fair test
- Find the next box. The box after Fair test is Collect evidence.Collect evidence
- Write the answer. Collect evidence
Check. The test gives evidence, and the evidence decides whether to support or refute the idea. ✓
Method. Think about what the test changed.
- Read the claim. Aisha says the colour of the car makes it roll further.colour
- Decide. A test of colour would be needed to show this, and there is no such test, so the answer is no.no
- Write the answer. no
Check. A claim needs fair evidence before it is a conclusion. ✓
Method. Think about what makes a result more reliable.
- Think about the test. More reliable results come from careful, repeated, precise and fair tests.repeated, precise, fair
- Write one way. Any one of these ways increases the degree of trust.one way
- Write the answer. Accept any one of: repeat the test, use a more precise instrument, keep the control variables the same.
Check. Each of these makes a result more trusted. ✓
Method. Think about how closely the results agree.
- Read the results. The three results are between 41 cm and 45 cm, so they are close together.close together
- Decide. Results that agree closely are more trusted, so the answer is yes.yes
- Write the answer. yes
Check. Agreement between repeats is a sign of a reliable test. ✓
Method. Think about mistakes and chance.
- Think about one result. One result can be spoiled by one mistake or by chance.one mistake
- Write the reason. If a second result agrees, a single mistake is less likely.less likely
- Write the answer. Accept any sentence that says two results that agree make it less likely that one mistake or chance caused the result.
Check. Agreement between results is evidence of reliability. ✓
Chapter summary
| Skill | Method |
|---|---|
| Fair tests | Change only the independent variable. Measure the dependent variable. Keep the control variables the same. |
| Measuring | Use an instrument with a fine scale. Take repeat readings, leave out any clear anomaly, and find the mean. |
| Recording and graphs | Use tables with units. Bar charts compare groups, line graphs show change over time, and scatter graphs show patterns. |
| Predicting | Predict from the pattern in the evidence, and test the prediction with a further fair test. |
| Reporting | Write a conclusion that matches the results, and say how much the results can be trusted. |
| Evidence | Evidence supports an idea when it agrees with it, and refutes the idea when it does not. |
Can you…?
- I can name the independent, dependent and control variables in a test
- I can choose an instrument with a fine scale, and find the mean of repeat readings
- I can record results in a table and choose a bar chart, line graph or scatter graph
- I can read values from a graph, and use the pattern to make a prediction
- I can plan a further test, changing one thing only
- I can write a conclusion that matches the results, and say whether evidence supports or refutes an idea
Key terms
- independent variable
- the variable you change on purpose in a test
- dependent variable
- the variable you measure; it depends on the change you make
- control variable
- a variable that is kept the same, so that the test is fair
- fair test
- a test in which only one thing is changed
- precision
- how finely a measurement can be read on a scale
- accuracy
- how close a measurement is to the true value
- mean
- the total of several results, divided by how many results there are
- anomalous result
- a result that is very different from the others
- prediction
- a sensible guess about what will happen, based on the evidence
- conclusion
- what the results show, written so that it matches the evidence
- causal relationship
- when one thing causes a change in another
- refute
- to show that evidence goes against an idea
Exercise 1Z Check-up
Method. Read the label that says changed on purpose.
- Read the label. The label says Changed on purpose: ramp height.Changed on purpose
- Name the variable. So the variable changed on purpose is the ramp height.ramp height
- Write the answer. ramp height
Check. The ramp height is the independent variable. ✓
Method. Read the label that says measured.
- Read the label. The label says Measured: distance rolled.Measured
- Name the variable. So the variable measured is the distance rolled.distance rolled
- Write the answer. distance rolled
Check. The distance rolled is the dependent variable. ✓
Method. Add the three readings, then divide by three.
- Add them. The three readings add to 39 cm.12 + 14 + 13 = 39
- Divide. Divide 39 by 3 to find the mean.39 divided by 3 is 13
- Write the answer. 13
Check. Check: 13 + 13 + 13 = 39. ✓
Method. Think about the graph with points that are not joined.
- Read the description. A scatter graph shows two measured variables, with points that are not joined.not joined
- Name the graph. So the answer is a scatter graph.scatter graph
- Write the answer. scatter graph
Check. Scatter graphs are used to look for a pattern. ✓
Method. Find 10 cm on the height axis, then read the point above it.
- Find the height. Follow the horizontal axis to 10 cm.10 cm
- Read the distance. The point above 10 cm is at 55 cm.55
- Write the answer. 55
Check. The table says 55 cm for a 10 cm ramp. ✓
Method. Read the three trials, then find the mean.
- Read the trials. The three trials are 41 cm, 45 cm and 43 cm.41, 45, 43
- Find the mean. They add to 129 cm, and 129 divided by 3 is 43.129 divided by 3 is 43
- Write the answer. 43
Check. The mean is marked by the triangle on the number line. ✓
Method. Add the three numbers, then divide by three.
- Add them. The three numbers add to 75.20 + 25 + 30 = 75
- Divide. Divide 75 by 3 to find the mean.75 divided by 3 is 25
- Write the answer. yes
Check. Check: 25 + 25 + 25 = 75. ✓
Method. Read the boxes from left to right.
- Read the first box. The boxes in order are Idea, Fair test, Collect evidence, and Support or refute the idea.Idea first
- Name the first box. So the box that comes before the fair test is Idea.Idea
- Write the answer. Idea
Check. Every enquiry starts with an idea. ✓
Method. Find 15 minutes on the time axis, then read the point above it.
- Find the time. Follow the time axis to 15 minutes.15 minutes
- Read the temperature. The point above 15 minutes is at 35 degrees.35
- Write the answer. 35
Check. The table says 35 degrees at 15 minutes. ✓
Method. Think about the fair test and the conclusion.
- Think about the test. Only the ramp height changed, so the test was fair.fair test
- Think about the conclusion. The results show a longer distance on a higher ramp, so the conclusion matches the results.matches
- Write the answer. yes. Accept any reason that says only the ramp height changed, so the test was fair, and the results support the conclusion.
Check. A fair test with matching results supports the conclusion. ✓
Total 19 marks. Allow about 19 minutes.
Exercise 1X Practice test questions
Method. Think about the variables that are kept the same.
- Read the definition. Variables that are kept the same in a fair test are called control variables.kept the same
- Name them. The word is control variable.control variable
- Write the answer. control variable
Check. Control variables keep the test fair. ✓
Method. Think about which variable is measured.
- Read the test. Ruby changes the ramp height on purpose, and measures the distance.measures the distance
- Name the variable. The variable that is measured is the dependent variable.dependent
- Write the answer. dependent
Check. The independent variable is the one that is changed on purpose. ✓
Method. Compare the smallest steps.
- Compare the steps. A step of 1 degree is smaller than a step of 5 degrees.smaller step
- Choose the more precise one. The smaller step, 1 degree, is the more precise thermometer.1 degree
- Write the answer. 1 degree
Check. A finer scale allows a more precise reading. ✓
Method. Add the three trials, then divide by three.
- Add them. The three trials add to 186 cm.60 + 64 + 62 = 186
- Divide by three. Divide 186 by 3 to find the mean.186 divided by 3 is 62
- Write the answer. 62
Check. Check: 62 + 62 + 62 = 186. ✓
Method. Leave out the anomalous result, then find the mean of the other three.
- Leave out the anomaly. The three results left are 9 cm, 10 cm and 11 cm.9, 10, 11
- Find the mean. They add to 30 cm, and 30 divided by 3 is 10.30 divided by 3 is 10
- Write the answer. 10
Check. Check: 10 + 10 + 10 = 30. ✓
Method. Find the shortest bar.
- Find the shortest bar. The shortest bar is for Cardboard, at 4 ml.4 ml
- Read the label. The label under that bar says Cardboard.Cardboard
- Write the answer. Cardboard
Check. Cardboard soaked up 4 ml, the least of the four materials. ✓
Method. Find the points on either side of 9 cm.
- Find the points. The points on either side of 9 cm are 8 cm and 10 cm.8 cm and 10 cm
- Read the distances. The distances for those heights are 47 cm and 55 cm, so the answer lies between them.47 and 55
- Write the answer. between 47 cm and 55 cm
Check. A prediction for a value between two measured values lies between their results. ✓
Method. Find the thing that is measured.
- Find the change. The mass of the car is changed on purpose, so it is the independent variable.mass of the car
- Find the measurement. The time taken to roll down the ramp is measured, so it is the dependent variable.time taken
- Write the answer. time taken to roll down the ramp
Check. The time depends on the mass chosen. ✓
Method. Think about the results and the test.
- Write the conclusion. The conclusion must match the results: the car rolled a shorter distance on the rough surface.shorter distance
- Give a reason. A reason for trust is that the test was fair, or that it was repeated and the results agreed.fair or repeated
- Write the answer. Accept any answer that gives a conclusion matching the results (rough surfaces make the car roll a shorter distance), and a reason such as the test was fair or was repeated.
Check. A good conclusion matches the results and gives a reason for trust. ✓
Method. Think about how many things changed.
- Count the changes. Two things changed at the same time: the mass and the ramp height.two things
- Decide. A fair test changes only one thing, so the test is not fair, and the cause cannot be shown.not fair
- Write the answer. no. Accept any reason that says two things were changed at once, so the test cannot show what caused the result.
Check. Only one thing should change in a fair test. ✓