Commas, brackets and dashes for clarity
By the end of this chapter you will be able to
- Put a comma after a fronted adverbial
- Separate the items in a list with commas
- Use a comma so that the reader cannot misread the sentence
- Mark extra information with a pair of brackets, dashes or commas, using the same mark on both sides
- Find and correct a missing or an extra comma
You should already know
- Lists and the words that describe a noun (Year 4 grammar)
- Fronted adverbials and adverbials of time, place and number (Chapter 3 of this book)
Where this leads
- Speech punctuation (Chapter 6 of this book)
KS2 SATs practice for grammar, punctuation and spelling (Year 6). Original questions in the style of the national tests. Content: Use a comma after a fronted adverbial, before the main clause (Year 5-6 grammar), Use commas to separate items in a list (Year 5-6 grammar), Use a comma to avoid ambiguity, for example Let's eat, Grandma (Year 5-6 grammar), Use brackets, dashes or a pair of commas for extra information (parenthesis), and use one rule in each sentence (Year 5-6 grammar), Find a missing or an extra comma, and correct it (Year 5-6 grammar).
Exercise P Do you remember?
Method. A sentence begins with a capital letter and ends with a full stop.
- Add the capital. The first word begins the sentence.The cat slept on the mat
- Add the full stop. A statement ends with a full stop.The cat slept on the mat.
- Write the answer. The cat slept on the mat.
Check. the sentence has a capital and a full stop. ✓
Method. Test each choice against the sentence.
- Read what the sentence needs. Decide which job the missing or marked word does.
- Test the choice. Sang is the action the children did.sang fits
- Reject the other choices. Children is a noun, and the is a determiner.children and The do not fit
- Write the answer. sang
Check. sang fits the sentence. ✓
Method. Count the items separated by commas and by and.
- Find the items. Apples, pears and plums are the items.apples, pears, plums
- Count them. There are three items.3
- Write the answer. 3
Check. three items are in the list. ✓
Method. An adverb tells how, when or where.
- Find the verb. Opened is the verb.opened
- Find the word that tells how. Carefully tells how she opened the box.carefully
- Write the answer. carefully
Check. carefully tells how. ✓
Method. Test each choice against the sentence.
- Read what the sentence needs. Decide which job the missing or marked word does.
- Test the choice. A noun names a thing, and tree names a thing.tree fits
- Reject the other choices. Tall is an adjective, and swayed is a verb.tall and swayed do not fit
- Write the answer. tree
Check. tree fits the sentence. ✓
Commas after fronted adverbials
Rule
A fronted adverbial is a word or phrase at the start of a sentence that tells when, where or how. It is followed by a comma before the main clause: After the storm, the lake was calm.
A single word is also followed by a comma: Finally, we reached the gate.
Key ideas
- A fronted adverbial is at the start of a sentence and tells when, where or how.
- Put a comma after it, before the main clause.
- Without the comma, the reader may pause in the wrong place.
Method. A fronted adverbial is followed by a comma.
- Find the fronted adverbial. After the storm tells when.After the storm
- Find the main clause. The lake was calm is the main clause.the lake was calm
- Insert the comma. The comma goes between the two.After the storm,
- Write the answer. After the storm, the lake was calm.
Check. the comma separates the adverbial from the main clause. ✓
Method. Put a comma after the fronted adverbial of place.
- Find the adverbial. Inside the tent tells where.Inside the tent
- Check the first version. Without a comma, the adverbial runs into the main clause.no comma
- Choose the correct version. The second version has the comma after the adverbial.Inside the tent, it was warm.
- Write the answer. Inside the tent, it was warm.
Check. the comma follows the adverbial. ✓
Method. The fronted adverbial comes first and is followed by a comma.
- Find the first words. Without warning starts the sentence.Without warning
- Check the comma. The comma after warning ends the adverbial.Without warning,
- Check the main clause. The rain began is the main clause.the rain began
- Write the answer. Without warning
Check. without warning is the adverbial. ✓
Exercise 5A Practice: commas after fronted adverbials
Method. Put a comma after the adverbial of time.
- Find the adverbial. At midnight tells when.At midnight
- Insert the comma. It goes before the main clause.At midnight,
- Write the answer. At midnight, the church bells rang.
Check. the comma follows the adverbial. ✓
Method. A single word that starts the sentence is followed by a comma.
- Find the adverb. Eventually tells when the queue moved.Eventually
- Insert the comma. The comma follows the single adverb.Eventually,
- Write the answer. Eventually, the queue moved forwards.
Check. the comma follows the adverb. ✓
Method. Test each choice against the sentence.
- Read what the sentence needs. Decide which job the missing or marked word does.
- Test the choice. The comma comes after the fronted adverbial of place.Under the bridge, the ducks rested. fits
- Reject the other choices. The comma after ducks splits the subject and verb, and the others break up the adverbial.Under the bridge the ducks, rested. and Under, the bridge the ducks rested. do not fit
- Write the answer. Under the bridge, the ducks rested.
Check. Under the bridge, the ducks rested. fits the sentence. ✓
Method. The fronted adverbial is the words before the comma.
- Find the comma. The comma comes after hill.Over the hill,
- Copy the words before it. Over the hill is the adverbial.Over the hill
- Write the answer. Over the hill
Check. over the hill is the adverbial. ✓
Method. Test each choice against the sentence.
- Read what the sentence needs. Decide which job the missing or marked word does.
- Test the choice. Quietly is a fronted adverbial, so a comma follows it.True fits
- Reject the other choices. The comma is needed, so False is wrong.False do not fit
- Write the answer. True
Check. True fits the sentence. ✓
Method. Put a comma after the fronted adverbial of time.
- Find the adverbial. In the morning tells when.In the morning
- Insert the comma. The comma goes before the main clause.In the morning,
- Write the answer. In the morning, the children set off for school.
Check. the comma follows the adverbial. ✓
Method. A fronted adverbial of time tells when, and is followed by a comma.
- Find the comma. The comma follows that day.Later that day,
- Name the words before it. Later that day tells when the wind dropped.Later that day
- Write the answer. Later that day
Check. later that day is the adverbial of time. ✓
Method. Test each choice against the sentence.
- Read what the sentence needs. Decide which job the missing or marked word does.
- Test the choice. The comma comes straight after the adverbial.In the valley, the river is calm. fits
- Reject the other choices. Commas in the other two places break the sentence in the wrong places.In, the valley the river is calm. and In the valley the, river is calm. do not fit
- Write the answer. In the valley, the river is calm.
Check. In the valley, the river is calm. fits the sentence. ✓
Method. Start with the place, then add a comma before the main clause.
- Choose the adverbial. Beneath the old oak tells where.Beneath the old oak
- Add the comma and the main clause. The comma goes before we ate our lunch.Beneath the old oak, we ate our lunch.
- Write the answer. Beneath the old oak, we ate our lunch.
Check. the adverbial tells where. ✓
Method. A single word adverb at the start is followed by a comma.
- Find the adverb. Quickly tells how they reached the house.Quickly
- Insert the comma. The comma comes after the adverb.Quickly,
- Write the answer. Quickly, the firefighters reached the house.
Check. the comma follows quickly. ✓
Method. Think about where the reader pauses.
- Find the adverbial. Without his coat is the adverbial.Without his coat
- Find the main clause. Tom went outside is the main clause.Tom went outside
- Write the answer. It shows where the adverbial ends and the main clause begins.
Check. the comma marks the pause. ✓
Method. Put a comma after the adverbial of place.
- Find the adverbial. Behind the wall tells where.Behind the wall
- Insert the comma. The comma goes before the main clause.Behind the wall,
- Write the answer. Behind the wall, a dog barked loudly.
Check. the comma follows the adverbial. ✓
Commas in lists
Rule
Use commas to separate the items in a list: apples, pears, plums. In this book, the last two items are joined with and, with no comma before and: apples, pears and plums.
Adjectives before a noun are separated by commas: a big, warm, waterproof coat.
Key ideas
- Separate the items in a list with commas.
- In this book, do not put a comma before and in the last item: a, b and c.
- Adjectives that describe the same noun are separated by commas.
Method. Commas separate the items, and and joins the last two.
- Find the items. Apples, pears and plums are the three items.apples, pears, plums
- Insert the commas. Commas go after the first two items.apples, pears
- Check the last item. There is no comma before and.and plums
- Write the answer. We packed apples, pears and plums.
Check. three items, separated by commas. ✓
Method. Adjectives that describe the same noun are separated by commas.
- Find the adjectives. Tall, thin and shy all describe the boy.tall, thin, shy
- Put commas between them. A comma goes between each adjective.tall, thin, shy
- Check the noun. Boy is the noun, and it stays last.a tall, thin, shy boy
- Write the answer. a tall, thin, shy boy
Check. the adjectives are separated. ✓
Method. Count the items in the list, not the words.
- Find the list. A torch, a map and a compass is the list.a torch, a map, a compass
- Count the items. There are three items.three
- Check. Each item is one thing in the bag.3
- Write the answer. 3
Check. three things are in the bag. ✓
Exercise 5B Practice: commas in lists
Method. Put a comma between each item, but not before and.
- Find the items. Bread, milk, eggs and cheese are the items.bread, milk, eggs, cheese
- Insert the commas. A comma separates each item except the last.bread, milk, eggs
- Write the answer. The shop sold bread, milk, eggs and cheese.
Check. commas separate the items. ✓
Method. Test each choice against the sentence.
- Read what the sentence needs. Decide which job the missing or marked word does.
- Test the choice. Commas separate the items, with no comma before and in this book.We saw a lion, a zebra and a giraffe. fits
- Reject the other choices. The second has no commas, and the third has a comma before the list and before and.We saw a lion a zebra and a giraffe. and We saw, a lion, a zebra, and a giraffe. do not fit
- Write the answer. We saw a lion, a zebra and a giraffe.
Check. We saw a lion, a zebra and a giraffe. fits the sentence. ✓
Method. Commas separate adjectives that describe the same noun.
- Find the adjectives. Big, gentle and friendly describe the dog.big, gentle, friendly
- Insert the commas. A comma goes between each adjective.big, gentle, friendly dog
- Write the answer. a big, gentle, friendly dog
Check. the adjectives are separated. ✓
Method. Count each separate thing in the list, not the words.
- Find the items. Pen, ruler, rubber and two pencils are the items.pen, ruler, rubber, two pencils
- Count them. Two pencils count as one item.4
- Write the answer. 4
Check. there are four items. ✓
Watch out. Two pencils is one item, even though it has two things in it.
Method. Separate each activity with a comma.
- Find the items. Swimming, running and cycling are the activities.swimming, running, cycling
- Insert the commas. A comma goes after swimming and running.swimming, running
- Write the answer. Ruby likes swimming, running and cycling.
Check. the activities are separated. ✓
Method. Test each choice against the sentence.
- Read what the sentence needs. Decide which job the missing or marked word does.
- Test the choice. Each item is separated by a comma, and the last is joined with and.The park has swings, slides and a pond. fits
- Reject the other choices. The other two have commas in the wrong places, and one list has none between swings and slides.The park has swings slides, and a pond. and The park has, swings slides and a pond. do not fit
- Write the answer. The park has swings, slides and a pond.
Check. The park has swings, slides and a pond. fits the sentence. ✓
Method. Separate each item with a comma.
- Find the items. Soup, salad, bread and tea are the items.soup, salad, bread, tea
- Insert the commas. A comma goes between each item, except before and.soup, salad, bread
- Write the answer. The café served soup, salad, bread and tea.
Check. four items are separated. ✓
Method. Think about what a list would look like with no commas.
- Look at a list with no commas. Pens paper glue run together and are hard to read.run together
- Name the job of the comma. A comma marks the boundary between items.boundary
- Write the answer. Commas show where one item ends and the next begins, so the reader does not run them together.
Check. the commas mark each item. ✓
Method. Put a comma between the items, but not before and.
- Find the items. A tent, a stove, a lamp and some water are the items.a tent, a stove, a lamp
- Insert the commas. Commas go between the items.a tent, a stove, a lamp
- Write the answer. We took a tent, a stove, a lamp and some water.
Check. the items are separated. ✓
Method. Test each choice against the sentence.
- Read what the sentence needs. Decide which job the missing or marked word does.
- Test the choice. Pens, paper and glue are exactly three items.The shop sold pens, paper and glue. fits
- Reject the other choices. Pens, paper, glue and tape is four items, and pens and paper is two items.The shop sold pens, paper, glue and tape. and The shop sold pens and paper. do not fit
- Write the answer. The shop sold pens, paper and glue.
Check. The shop sold pens, paper and glue. fits the sentence. ✓
Method. Choose three items, and separate them with commas.
- Choose the items. Three things for a picnic.a blanket, a flask, some sandwiches
- Insert the commas. A comma goes after the first two items.a blanket, a flask
- Write the answer. a blanket, a flask and some sandwiches.
Check. three items are separated. ✓
Method. Separate each verb with a comma.
- Find the verbs. Ran, jumped and landed are the verbs.ran, jumped, landed
- Insert the comma. A comma goes after ran.ran, jumped
- Write the answer. She ran, jumped and landed.
Check. the verbs are separated. ✓
Commas to avoid ambiguity
Rule
A comma can stop a sentence being misread. In Let's eat, Grandma, the comma shows that Grandma is the person spoken to. Without it, the sentence reads as if Grandma is the food.
A name that someone is spoken to is set off with commas: Thank you, Sam.
Key ideas
- A comma can show who is being spoken to: Mum, can you help?
- A comma can stop a reader misreading the meaning.
- When a name is spoken to, the name is set off with a comma.
Method. A comma shows the person being spoken to.
- Find the name. Grandma is the person spoken to.Grandma
- Set the name off with a comma. The comma shows Grandma is addressed.eat,
- Check the meaning. The sentence now means we are inviting Grandma to eat.Let's eat, Grandma.
- Write the answer. Let's eat, Grandma.
Check. the comma shows who is spoken to. ✓
Method. A name that someone is spoken to is set off with a comma.
- Find the name. Sam is the person spoken to.Sam
- Set it off. A comma goes before the name.you,
- Check the sentence. The name is clearly addressed.Thank you, Sam.
- Write the answer. Thank you, Sam.
Check. the name is set off with a comma. ✓
Method. A comma separates the first clause from the main clause, so the reader pauses in the right place.
- Find the first clause. When the dog barked starts the sentence.When the dog barked
- Find the main clause. The children ran inside is the main clause.the children ran inside
- Insert the comma. The comma comes before the main clause.barked,
- Write the answer. When the dog barked, the children ran inside.
Check. the comma separates the clauses. ✓
Exercise 5C Practice: commas to avoid ambiguity
Method. The comma shows that Grandpa is the person being spoken to.
- Find the name. Grandpa is spoken to.Grandpa
- Insert the comma. It goes before the name.cook,
- Write the answer. Let's cook, Grandpa.
Check. the comma shows who is addressed. ✓
Method. A name that is spoken to is set off with a comma.
- Find the name. Mum is the person spoken to.Mum
- Insert the comma. The comma goes before the name.you,
- Write the answer. Thank you, Mum.
Check. the name is set off. ✓
Method. Test each choice against the sentence.
- Read what the sentence needs. Decide which job the missing or marked word does.
- Test the choice. The apostrophe and the comma show the meaning clearly.Let's eat, Grandma. fits
- Reject the other choices. The first has no apostrophe or comma, and the third has no full stop.Lets eat Grandma. and Let's eat Grandma do not fit
- Write the answer. Let's eat, Grandma.
Check. Let's eat, Grandma. fits the sentence. ✓
Method. Put a comma after the first clause.
- Find the first clause. When the bell rang starts the sentence.When the bell rang
- Insert the comma. The comma goes before the main clause.rang,
- Write the answer. When the bell rang, the children went home.
Check. the comma separates the clauses. ✓
Method. Test each choice against the sentence.
- Read what the sentence needs. Decide which job the missing or marked word does.
- Test the choice. Mum is the person being spoken to, so a comma sets it off.True fits
- Reject the other choices. The comma is needed, so False is wrong.False do not fit
- Write the answer. True
Check. True fits the sentence. ✓
Method. A name spoken to is set off with commas on both sides, or one comma if at the end.
- Find the name. Anita is the person thanked.Anita
- Set it off. A comma goes before and after the name.you, Anita,
- Write the answer. Thank you, Anita, for the lovely card.
Check. the name is set off with two commas. ✓
Method. Think about who the speaker is talking to.
- Read the first sentence. Grandma is named as the person spoken to.Grandma spoken to
- Read the second sentence. Without the comma, the reader may not know who is addressed.unclear
- Write the answer. The comma shows that Grandma is the person being spoken to, not the food.
Check. the comma marks the person addressed. ✓
Method. The name spoken to is set off with a comma.
- Find the name. Mr Okafor is spoken to.Mr Okafor
- Insert the comma. The comma goes before the name.in,
- Write the answer. Please come in, Mr Okafor.
Check. the name is set off. ✓
Method. The name spoken to is set off with a comma.
- Find the name. Lily is spoken to.Lily
- Insert the comma. The comma goes before the name.down,
- Write the answer. Sit down, Lily.
Check. the name is set off. ✓
Method. Test each choice against the sentence.
- Read what the sentence needs. Decide which job the missing or marked word does.
- Test the choice. The comma shows Tom is spoken to.We cannot wait, Tom. fits
- Reject the other choices. The first could be misread, and the third has no full stop.We cannot wait Tom. and We cannot wait Tom do not fit
- Write the answer. We cannot wait, Tom.
Check. We cannot wait, Tom. fits the sentence. ✓
Method. Write a short instruction, then add a name with a comma.
- Write the instruction. Wait for me is the instruction.Wait for me
- Add the name. Jake is the person spoken to, set off with a comma.Jake
- Write the answer. Wait for me, Jake.
Check. the comma sets off the name. ✓
Method. A fronted clause is followed by a comma.
- Find the first clause. After the rain stopped starts the sentence.After the rain stopped
- Insert the comma. The comma goes before the main clause.stopped,
- Write the answer. After the rain stopped, the sun came out.
Check. the comma separates the clauses. ✓
Brackets, dashes and a pair of commas
Rule
Extra information can be marked with brackets (), dashes (–) or a pair of commas. The sentence still makes sense if the extra information is removed.
Use the same mark on both sides of the extra information. Do not mix a dash on one side with a comma on the other.
Key ideas
- Extra information sits between two matching marks: brackets, dashes or commas.
- The sentence still makes sense without the extra information.
- Use one kind of mark for each piece of extra information.
Method. Put one bracket before the extra information and one after it.
- Find the extra information. Which stands on the cliff adds detail.which stands on the cliff
- Add the opening bracket. The opening bracket goes before which.(
- Add the closing bracket. The closing bracket goes after cliff.The lighthouse (which stands on the cliff) is old.
- Write the answer. The lighthouse (which stands on the cliff) is old.
Check. the sentence makes sense without the brackets. ✓
Method. Replace the dashes with commas, using the same mark on both sides.
- Find the extra information. Tired and hungry describes the puppy.tired and hungry
- Replace the first dash. A comma replaces the dash before tired.puppy,
- Replace the second dash. A comma replaces the dash after hungry.The puppy, tired and hungry, fell asleep.
- Write the answer. The puppy, tired and hungry, fell asleep.
Check. both sides use a comma. ✓
Method. Both sides of the extra information must match.
- Find the opening mark. An opening bracket is at (who.(
- Find the missing closing mark. The bracket is never closed.tired
- Close the bracket. Add a closing bracket after tired.The coach (who was tired) shouted instructions.
- Write the answer. The coach (who was tired) shouted instructions.
Check. the bracket is closed. ✓
Exercise 5D Practice: brackets, dashes and a pair of commas
Method. Put a bracket before and after the extra information.
- Find the extra information. Which had a red roof describes the barn.which had a red roof
- Add the brackets. One bracket goes before and one after.The old barn (which had a red roof)
- Write the answer. The old barn (which had a red roof) collapsed in the storm.
Check. the sentence makes sense without the brackets. ✓
Method. Use the same mark on both sides of the extra information.
- Find the commas. A comma is before and after which opens at seven.the two commas
- Replace them. A dash goes in each place.The café – which opens at seven –
- Write the answer. The café – which opens at seven – is busy.
Check. the same mark is used on both sides. ✓
Method. Test each choice against the sentence.
- Read what the sentence needs. Decide which job the missing or marked word does.
- Test the choice. Both sides of the extra information use a bracket.Our dog (a small terrier) barked. fits
- Reject the other choices. The second has no closing bracket, and the third has a comma and a bracket mixed.Our dog (a small terrier, barked. and Our dog, a small terrier) barked. do not fit
- Write the answer. Our dog (a small terrier) barked.
Check. Our dog (a small terrier) barked. fits the sentence. ✓
Method. Test each choice against the sentence.
- Read what the sentence needs. Decide which job the missing or marked word does.
- Test the choice. The sentence opens with a dash but closes with a comma, so the marks do not match.False fits
- Reject the other choices. Use two dashes, or a pair of commas: Our house – which is old – has a garden.True do not fit
- Write the answer. False
Check. False fits the sentence. ✓
Method. Use a comma before and after the extra information.
- Find the extra information. Who teaches Year 6 adds detail about Mr Hale.who teaches Year 6
- Add the pair of commas. A comma goes before and after it.Mr Hale, who teaches Year 6,
- Write the answer. Mr Hale, who teaches Year 6, is my uncle.
Check. a pair of commas marks the extra information. ✓
Method. Every opening bracket needs a closing bracket.
- Find the open bracket. The bracket opens before which.(
- Close it. The closing bracket goes after bread.The shop (which sells bread)
- Write the answer. The shop (which sells bread) is open.
Check. the bracket is closed. ✓
Method. Write the place, then the extra information in brackets.
- Name the place. The park is the place.The park
- Add the bracketed information. Which is near the school gives the location.(which is near the school)
- Write the answer. The park (which is near the school) has a pond.
Check. the brackets are closed. ✓
Method. Test each choice against the sentence.
- Read what the sentence needs. Decide which job the missing or marked word does.
- Test the choice. Both sides use a comma, so the extra information is marked.The bridge, which was built in 1900, is long. fits
- Reject the other choices. The first mixes a comma and a dash, and the third has only one comma.The bridge, which was built in 1900 – is long. and The bridge which was built in 1900, is long. do not fit
- Write the answer. The bridge, which was built in 1900, is long.
Check. The bridge, which was built in 1900, is long. fits the sentence. ✓
Method. Brackets can replace a pair of commas, but both sides must match.
- Find the extra information. Who was tired adds detail.who was tired
- Replace the commas with brackets. One bracket goes before and one after.The coach (who was tired)
- Write the answer. The coach (who was tired) shouted.
Check. brackets mark the extra information. ✓
Method. Think about what the reader needs in a formal report.
- Think about the main sentence. The main sentence still makes sense without brackets.main sentence
- Think about the extra detail. The brackets make the extra detail easy to see and skip.easy to see
- Write the answer. Brackets keep extra information separate, and the main sentence still reads clearly without it.
Check. the extra information is kept separate. ✓
Method. Use a dash before and after the extra information.
- Find the extra information. Built last year adds detail about the bridge.built last year
- Add the closing dash. The closing dash goes after year.The new bridge – built last year –
- Write the answer. The new bridge – built last year – is busy.
Check. the extra information is between two dashes. ✓
Method. Write the main clause, then the extra information between two commas.
- Name the sea. The sea is the noun.The sea
- Add the extra information. Which was calm that morning is set off by commas.which was calm that morning
- Write the answer. The sea, which was calm that morning, sparkled.
Check. both commas are placed. ✓
Finding missing and extra commas
Rule
Check each comma: a comma is needed after a fronted adverbial, between items in a list, and around extra information. A comma is not needed between a subject and its verb, or after the verb.
Key ideas
- Look for a comma after a fronted adverbial.
- Look for commas between items in a list, and none before and in the last item.
- Do not put a comma between a subject and its verb.
Method. A comma goes before a conjunction that joins two main clauses, like so.
- Find the two main clauses. The last bus left early and we walked home.The last bus left early / we walked home
- Find the conjunction. So joins the two clauses.so
- Insert the comma. A comma goes before so.early,
- Write the answer. The last bus left early, so we walked home.
Check. the comma separates the clauses. ✓
Method. Commas separate items, but not between the verb and the list.
- Find the verb and the list. Packed is the verb, and a tent begins the list.packed
- Find the extra comma. The comma after packed separates the verb from its object.packed,
- Remove it. The list keeps its commas between items only.We packed a tent, a stove and a lamp.
- Write the answer. We packed a tent, a stove and a lamp.
Check. no comma separates the verb from its object. ✓
Method. Do not put a comma between a verb and the words that follow it.
- Find the adverbial. Yesterday is a fronted adverbial, and its comma is correct.Yesterday,
- Find the extra comma. The comma after went separates the verb from the place.went,
- Remove it. The sentence reads smoothly without it.Yesterday, we went to the park.
- Write the answer. Yesterday, we went to the park.
Check. the sentence has one comma after the adverbial only. ✓
Exercise 5E Practice: finding missing and extra commas
Method. A comma should not come between the subject and the verb.
- Find the subject and verb. The dog is the subject, and ran is the verb.The dog / ran
- Remove the comma. The comma between them is not needed.The dog ran across the field.
- Write the answer. The dog ran across the field.
Check. no comma separates the subject and the verb. ✓
Method. A fronted adverbial is followed by a comma.
- Find the adverbial. After the match tells when.After the match
- Insert the comma. It goes before the main clause.After the match,
- Write the answer. After the match, we went home.
Check. the comma follows the adverbial. ✓
Method. Test each choice against the sentence.
- Read what the sentence needs. Decide which job the missing or marked word does.
- Test the choice. Commas separate the items, with no comma before and.We bought bread, milk and eggs. fits
- Reject the other choices. The second has a comma after bought, and the third has a comma before and but none between bread and milk.We bought, bread milk and eggs. and We bought bread milk, and eggs. do not fit
- Write the answer. We bought bread, milk and eggs.
Check. We bought bread, milk and eggs. fits the sentence. ✓
Method. Extra information needs a comma on both sides.
- Find the extra information. Who lives in Leeds describes my sister.who lives in Leeds
- Add the missing comma. A comma goes after Leeds to close it.Leeds,
- Write the answer. My sister, who lives in Leeds, visits us often.
Check. the extra information has a comma on both sides. ✓
Method. Test each choice against the sentence.
- Read what the sentence needs. Decide which job the missing or marked word does.
- Test the choice. The commas set off the extra information after the first word.True fits
- Reject the other choices. The sentence is correct, so False is wrong.False do not fit
- Write the answer. True
Check. True fits the sentence. ✓
Method. A fronted adverbial of place is followed by a comma.
- Find the adverbial. Behind the hedge tells where.Behind the hedge
- Insert the comma. It goes before a fox.Behind the hedge,
- Write the answer. Behind the hedge, a fox was hiding.
Check. the comma follows the adverbial. ✓
Method. No comma separates a subject from its verb.
- Find the subject and verb. The cat is the subject, and sat is the verb.The cat / sat
- Remove the comma. The sentence reads smoothly.The cat sat on the warm mat.
- Write the answer. The cat sat on the warm mat.
Check. no comma between subject and verb. ✓
Method. Count the subjects and verbs.
- Find the first clause. Dad cooked the rice has a subject and verb.Dad cooked the rice
- Find the second clause. We set the table has its own subject and verb.we set the table
- Write the answer. The comma separates two main clauses, each with its own subject and verb.
Check. two main clauses are joined. ✓
Method. Put a comma between each item in the list, but not before and.
- Find the items. A hare, a fox and a badger are the items.a hare, a fox, a badger
- Insert the commas. Commas go between hare and fox.hare, a fox
- Write the answer. We saw a hare, a fox and a badger.
Check. the items are separated. ✓
Method. Test each choice against the sentence.
- Read what the sentence needs. Decide which job the missing or marked word does.
- Test the choice. The comma comes after the adverbial, before the main clause.In the morning, we left. fits
- Reject the other choices. The other two put the comma inside the adverbial or between the subject and verb.In the, morning we left. and In the morning we, left. do not fit
- Write the answer. In the morning, we left.
Check. In the morning, we left. fits the sentence. ✓
Method. A phrase at the start is followed by a comma before the main clause.
- Find the opening phrase. Hurrying to the bus stop starts the sentence.Hurrying to the bus stop
- Insert the comma. The comma goes before Ali.stop,
- Write the answer. Hurrying to the bus stop, Ali dropped his bag.
Check. the comma separates the phrase from the main clause. ✓
Method. The extra information needs a comma before which, and the verb needs no comma.
- Find the extra information. Which opened last week describes the shop.which opened last week
- Add the comma before which. The first comma goes after shop.shop,
- Remove the comma after sells. No comma separates the verb from its object.sells fresh bread
- Write the answer. The shop, which opened last week, sells fresh bread.
Check. two corrections make the sentence correct. ✓
Chapter summary
| Skill | Method |
|---|---|
| Fronted adverbial | Put a comma after it, before the main clause: After the storm, the lake was calm. |
| Commas in a list | Separate items with commas, and no comma before and in the last item. |
| Commas for clarity | A comma can show who is spoken to: Let's eat, Grandma. |
| Extra information | A pair of brackets, dashes or commas, with the same mark on both sides. |
| Missing or extra comma | Check for a comma after a fronted adverbial, and none between subject and verb. |
Can you…?
- I can put a comma after a fronted adverbial
- I can separate the items in a list with commas, with no comma before and
- I can use a comma to avoid misreading a sentence, such as Let's eat, Grandma
- I can mark extra information with a matching pair of brackets, dashes or commas
- I can find a missing or an extra comma, and correct it
Key terms
- fronted adverbial
- a word or phrase at the start of a sentence that tells when, where or how
- list
- a set of items separated by commas
- parenthesis
- extra information in a sentence, set off by brackets, dashes or commas
- ambiguous
- able to be understood in more than one way
- main clause
- a clause that makes sense on its own
- address
- the name of the person being spoken to, such as Anita in Thank you, Anita
Exercise 5Z Check-up
Method. A fronted adverbial of time is followed by a comma.
- Find the adverbial. On Sunday tells when.On Sunday
- Insert the comma. It goes before the main clause.On Sunday,
- Write the answer. On Sunday, we visited the zoo.
Check. the comma follows the adverbial. ✓
Method. Separate each item with a comma, but not before and.
- Find the items. Flour, eggs, milk and sugar are the items.flour, eggs, milk, sugar
- Insert the commas. Commas go between the items.flour, eggs, milk
- Write the answer. We need flour, eggs, milk and sugar.
Check. the items are separated. ✓
Method. Test each choice against the sentence.
- Read what the sentence needs. Decide which job the missing or marked word does.
- Test the choice. The extra information has a comma on both sides.Ben, my brother, is ten. fits
- Reject the other choices. The second has only one comma, and the third has a comma in the wrong place.Ben, my brother is ten. and Ben my brother, is ten. do not fit
- Write the answer. Ben, my brother, is ten.
Check. Ben, my brother, is ten. fits the sentence. ✓
Method. A name spoken to is set off with a comma.
- Find the name. Ruby is spoken to.Ruby
- Insert the comma. The comma goes before the name.you,
- Write the answer. Thank you, Ruby.
Check. the name is set off. ✓
Method. Put a bracket before and after the extra information.
- Find the extra information. Which runs through the town describes the river.which runs through the town
- Add the brackets. One bracket goes before and one after.The river (which runs through the town)
- Write the answer. The river (which runs through the town) is clean.
Check. the sentence makes sense without the brackets. ✓
Method. Test each choice against the sentence.
- Read what the sentence needs. Decide which job the missing or marked word does.
- Test the choice. The pair of commas marks the extra information.True fits
- Reject the other choices. The sentence is correct, so False is wrong.False do not fit
- Write the answer. True
Check. True fits the sentence. ✓
Method. No comma comes between the subject and the verb.
- Find the subject and verb. My bag is the subject, and has is the verb.My bag / has
- Remove the comma. The sentence reads smoothly without it.My bag has a broken strap.
- Write the answer. My bag has a broken strap.
Check. no comma between subject and verb. ✓
Method. A fronted adverbial is followed by a comma.
- Find the adverbial. In the evening tells when.In the evening
- Insert the comma. It goes before the main clause.In the evening,
- Write the answer. In the evening, the crowds left.
Check. the comma follows the adverbial. ✓
Method. Write the main clause, then add the extra information between two commas.
- Name the person. Our teacher is the subject.Our teacher
- Add the extra information. Who is from Wales is set off by commas.who is from Wales
- Write the answer. Our teacher, who is from Wales, loves rugby.
Check. both commas are placed. ✓
Method. A fronted clause is followed by a comma.
- Find the first clause. When the bell rings starts the sentence.When the bell rings
- Insert the comma. The comma goes before the main clause.rings,
- Write the answer. When the bell rings, everyone must line up.
Check. the comma separates the clauses. ✓
Total 15 marks. Allow about 15 minutes.
Exercise 5X Practice test questions
Method. A fronted adverbial is followed by a comma.
- Find the adverbial. Without a word tells how the stranger left.Without a word
- Insert the comma. It goes before the main clause.Without a word,
- Write the answer. Without a word, the stranger left.
Check. the comma follows the adverbial. ✓
Method. Test each choice against the sentence.
- Read what the sentence needs. Decide which job the missing or marked word does.
- Test the choice. Commas separate the items, and there is no comma before and.She packed socks, a jumper and a hat. fits
- Reject the other choices. The second has no commas, and the third has a comma after packed and before and.She packed socks a jumper and a hat. and She packed, socks, a jumper, and a hat. do not fit
- Write the answer. She packed socks, a jumper and a hat.
Check. She packed socks, a jumper and a hat. fits the sentence. ✓
Method. Separate each item with a comma, but not before and.
- Find the items. Figs, dates, nuts and raisins are the items.figs, dates, nuts, raisins
- Insert the commas. Commas go between the items.figs, dates, nuts
- Write the answer. The market sold figs, dates, nuts and raisins.
Check. the items are separated. ✓
Method. Put a bracket before and after the extra information.
- Find the extra information. Which opened in 1902 describes the museum.which opened in 1902
- Add the brackets. One bracket goes before and one after.The museum (which opened in 1902)
- Write the answer. The museum (which opened in 1902) has a new wing.
Check. the sentence still reads clearly. ✓
Method. The comma shows that Grandma is the person spoken to.
- Find the name. Grandma is spoken to.Grandma
- Insert the comma. It goes before the name.feed,
- Write the answer. Let's feed, Grandma.
Check. the comma shows who is addressed. ✓
Method. Test each choice against the sentence.
- Read what the sentence needs. Decide which job the missing or marked word does.
- Test the choice. The pair of commas marks the extra information.The lake, which was frozen, cracked. fits
- Reject the other choices. The second has one comma only, and the third has a comma in the wrong place.The lake, which was frozen cracked. and The lake which was frozen, cracked. do not fit
- Write the answer. The lake, which was frozen, cracked.
Check. The lake, which was frozen, cracked. fits the sentence. ✓
Method. No comma separates the subject from the verb.
- Find the subject and verb. The children is the subject, and packed is the verb.the children / packed
- Remove the comma. The sentence reads smoothly without it.the children packed
- Write the answer. After the lesson, the children packed their bags.
Check. no comma between subject and verb. ✓
Method. Put a comma before and after the extra information.
- Find the extra information. Who was elected last year describes the mayor.who was elected last year
- Add the pair of commas. A comma goes before and after it.The mayor, who was elected last year,
- Write the answer. The mayor, who was elected last year, opened the park.
Check. a pair of commas marks the extra information. ✓
Method. Test each choice against the sentence.
- Read what the sentence needs. Decide which job the missing or marked word does.
- Test the choice. The comma follows the fronted adverbial of time.True fits
- Reject the other choices. The sentence is correct, so False is wrong.False do not fit
- Write the answer. True
Check. True fits the sentence. ✓
Method. Think about where the extra information starts and ends.
- Look at one comma. One comma marks only the start of the extra information.start only
- Look at two commas. Two commas mark where the extra information starts and ends.start and end
- Write the answer. One comma leaves the extra information running on into the rest of the sentence, so both sides need a comma.
Check. both ends are marked. ✓