Websink Prep UKGCSE MathsTextbook contentsMaths textbooksYear 1Year 2Year 4Year 5Year 6GCSEBrowse allPast papersFind a tutorBecome a tutor
GCSE Maths · EdexcelChapter 8 · Substitution and formulae
GCSE Maths · Substitution and Formulae · Higher · Lesson 8.8

GCSE Maths: Higher: the subject appears twice (Higher)

Part of the GCSE Maths substitution and formulae chapter (Higher). Chapter overview · whole chapter on one page · Download worksheet (PDF) · Answers (PDF)

Download worksheet (PDF)Answers (PDF)
8.8

Higher: the subject appears twice

Edexcel 1MA1: A5
Grade 6-9

In 8.6 and 8.7 the subject appeared once, so we could peel the operations off one at a time. When the subject appears twice, as in ax + b = cx + d or y = x + 3x − 2, no single inverse operation will isolate it. We need a different plan: gather all the terms that contain the subject, factorise the subject out so that it appears only once, and then divide.

1. Clearfractions(multiply)2. Expandbrackets3. Collectsubject termson one side4. Factorisetake subjectoutside bracket5. Divideby thebracket
The five-step plan. Not every question needs every step: skip any step that is not needed.

Why does factorising work? Look at xy − x = 3. The letter x appears twice, but both terms contain it: xy is x × y and x is x × 1. So we can write x(y − 1) = 3. Now x appears once, multiplied by the bracket (y − 1), and we can divide both sides by that bracket. Remember from Chapter 7 that factorising is the reverse of expanding: x(y − 1) = xy − x.

Two details matter. First, when you multiply to clear a fraction, multiply every term on both sides (the whole of each side). Second, when a term crosses the equals sign its sign changes, which is the same as adding or subtracting it from both sides.

Key ideas

  • If the subject appears more than once, collect every term containing it on one side and everything else on the other.
  • Factorise the subject out: xy − x = x(y − 1).
  • Then divide both sides by the whole bracket.
  • Clear fractions first by multiplying both sides by the denominator, and expand brackets before collecting.

Watch out

After factorising you must divide by the whole bracket. From x(y − 1) = 3 + 2y we get x = (3 + 2y) ÷ (y − 1), with the whole of (y − 1) on the bottom. It is wrong to cancel the y in x(y − 1) = ... to leave x − 1.
Worked example 8.8.1
Make x the subject of ax + b = cx + d.

Key words. When the subject (the letter we want) appears twice, we cannot simply undo operations one at a time. Instead we collect every term containing the subject on one side, factorise it out (write it as a product, with the subject outside a bracket), and then divide.

Method. Collect the terms containing the subject on one side, factorise the subject out, then divide.

  1. Write the formula. The subject x appears on both sides, so we cannot undo one operation at a time.
    ax + b = cx + d
  2. Collect every term containing x on the left and every other term on the right. Subtract cx from both sides and subtract b from both sides. Each time a term crosses the equals sign its sign changes.
    ax − cx = d − b
  3. Factorise the left side. Both terms contain x. Take x outside a bracket and put what is left inside.
    x(a − c) = d − b
  4. Divide both sides by the bracket. x is multiplied by (a − c), so divide both sides by it.
    x = d − ba − c

Check. Pick numbers for the other letters: a = 4, b = 10, c = 5, d = 6. The new formula gives
x = 6 − 104 − 5 = −4−1 = 4
Now put x = 4 back into the original formula. Left side: 4 × 4 + 10 = 16 + 10 = 26. Right side: 5 × 4 + 6 = 20 + 6 = 26. Both sides are equal, so the rearranging is correct. ✓

Watch out. Terms with the subject go on one side and all other terms on the other. When you move a term across the equals sign, its sign changes. Remember to multiply every term when you clear a fraction.

Worked example 8.8.2
Make x the subject of a(x + b) = c(x + d).

Key words. When the subject (the letter we want) appears twice, we cannot simply undo operations one at a time. Instead we collect every term containing the subject on one side, factorise it out (write it as a product, with the subject outside a bracket), and then divide.

Method. Expand the brackets, collect the terms containing the subject, factorise, then divide.

  1. Write the formula. x is inside brackets on both sides.
    a(x + b) = c(x + d)
  2. Expand both brackets. Multiply everything inside each bracket by the number outside.
    ax + ab = cx + cd
  3. Collect the x terms on the left and the others on the right. Subtract cx and ab from both sides.
    ax − cx = cd − ab
  4. Factorise the left side. Take x outside a bracket.
    x(a − c) = cd − ab
  5. Divide both sides by the bracket. Divide by (a − c).
    x = cd − aba − c

Check. Pick numbers for the other letters: a = 8, b = 3, c = 6, d = 5. The new formula gives
x = 6 × 5 − 8 × 38 − 6 = 30 − 242 = 62 = 3
Now put x = 3 back into the original formula. Left side: 8 × (3 + 3) = 8 × 6 = 48. Right side: 6 × (3 + 5) = 6 × 8 = 48. Both sides are equal, so the rearranging is correct. ✓

Watch out. Terms with the subject go on one side and all other terms on the other. When you move a term across the equals sign, its sign changes. Remember to multiply every term when you clear a fraction.

Worked example 8.8.3
Make x the subject of y = x + 3x − 2.

Key words. When the subject (the letter we want) appears twice, we cannot simply undo operations one at a time. Instead we collect every term containing the subject on one side, factorise it out (write it as a product, with the subject outside a bracket), and then divide.

Method. Clear the fraction, expand, collect the subject terms, factorise, then divide.

  1. Write the formula. x appears on the top and the bottom of the fraction.
    y = x + 3x − 2
  2. Multiply both sides by the bottom, (x − 2). This removes the fraction. The whole of the bottom is multiplied.
    y(x − 2) = x + 3
  3. Expand the bracket. Multiply both terms inside by y.
    yx − 2y = x + 3
  4. Collect the x terms on the left and the others on the right. Subtract x from both sides and add 2y to both sides.
    yx − x = 3 + 2y
  5. Factorise the left side. Take x outside a bracket.
    x(y − 1) = 3 + 2y
  6. Divide both sides by the bracket. Divide by (y − 1).
    x = 3 + 2yy − 1

Check. Pick numbers for the other letters: y = 6. The new formula gives
x = 3 + 2 × 66 − 1 = 3 + 125 = 155 = 3
Now put x = 3 back into the original formula. Left side: 6. Right side: 3 + 33 − 2 = 61 = 6. Both sides are equal, so the rearranging is correct. ✓

Watch out. Terms with the subject go on one side and all other terms on the other. When you move a term across the equals sign, its sign changes. Remember to multiply every term when you clear a fraction.

Worked example 8.8.4
Make x the subject of y = ax + bcx + d.

Key words. When the subject (the letter we want) appears twice, we cannot simply undo operations one at a time. Instead we collect every term containing the subject on one side, factorise it out (write it as a product, with the subject outside a bracket), and then divide.

Method. Clear the fraction, expand, collect the subject terms, factorise, then divide.

  1. Write the formula. x appears on the top and the bottom of the fraction.
    y = ax + bcx + d
  2. Multiply both sides by the bottom. This removes the fraction.
    y(cx + d) = ax + b
  3. Expand the bracket. Multiply both terms inside by y.
    ycx + yd = ax + b
  4. Collect the x terms on the left and the others on the right. Subtract ax and yd from both sides.
    ycx − ax = b − yd
  5. Factorise the left side. Take x outside a bracket.
    x(yc − a) = b − yd
  6. Divide both sides by the bracket. Divide by the whole bracket.
    x = b − ydyc − a

Watch out. Terms with the subject go on one side and all other terms on the other. When you move a term across the equals sign, its sign changes. Remember to multiply every term when you clear a fraction.

Exercise 8I  Subject appears twice

Non-calculator
1
FMake x the subject of each formula.
(a)Make x the subject of px + q = rx + s
(b)Make x the subject of b + ax = d + cx
(c)Make x the subject of mx + k = nx + t
2
FExpand the brackets, then make x the subject.
(a)Make x the subject of p(x + q) = r(x + s)
(b)Make x the subject of a(x + b) = c(x + d)
3
FMake x the subject of each formula.
(a)Make x the subject of y = ax + bx
(b)Make x the subject of y = px + qx
(c)Make x the subject of T = x + kx
4
FMake x the subject of each formula.
(a)Make x the subject of y = x + 3x − 2
(b)Make x the subject of y = x + 5x − 1
(c)Make x the subject of y = x + px − q
5
FMake x the subject of each formula.
(a)Make x the subject of y = ax + bcx + d
(b)Make x the subject of y = px + qrx + s
6
FMake x the subject of each formula.
(a)Make x the subject of ax2 + b = cx2 + d
(b)Make x the subject of px2 + q = rx2 + s
7
FMake n the subject.
(a)Make n the subject of a + bn = c + dn
8
PSFirm A charges £a plus £b per mile and Firm B charges £c plus £d per mile. The two firms charge the same for n miles when a + bn = c + dn.
(a)Make n the subject of a + bn = c + dn.
(b)Firm A charges £30 plus £4 per mile. Firm B charges £12 plus £7 per mile. For what distance do they charge the same?
9
FMake x the subject of xa + xb = c.
10
RAli is asked to make x the subject of xy − x = 3. He writes x(y − 1) = 3 and then x − 1 = 3y. Explain his mistake and give the correct answer.
11
RThe lens formula is 1f = 1u + 1v. Make v the subject.
12
R(a) Make x the subject of y = x + 1x − 1. (b) What do you notice about your answer? Use x = 3 to explain.
(a)Make x the subject
(b)What do you notice?

Websink Prep UK is an independent site. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by AQA, Pearson Edexcel, OCR, WJEC, Eduqas, CCEA, SQA, GL Assessment, CEM or the Department for Education. All exam board names and trademarks belong to their owners. Past papers are linked from the exam boards' own websites and are not hosted here.

About Websink Prep UK · Find a tutor · Privacy · Terms · Cookie settings