Year 4 English: Persuasive writing: opinion, reasons and a call to action
Part of the Year 4 English writing non-fiction and editing chapter. Chapter overview · whole chapter on one page
Persuasive writing: opinion, reasons and a call to action
Persuasion is writing that tries to make the reader agree with an opinion, or act. Its purpose is to persuade, and its audience is the reader it wants to convince. A persuasive text usually:
- states the opinion early, using words such as should;
- gives clear reasons, often introduced by First, Second, Third;
- may ask a rhetorical question, which makes the reader think; and
- ends with a call to action, which asks the reader to do something.
Read the text in the box, look at the structure of the argument, then answer the questions in exercise 12E.
Our library should stay open at lunchtime
Our school library should stay open at lunchtime. Many pupils finish their lunch quickly, and then they have nothing quiet to do.
First, reading helps us learn new words and ideas. Second, a lunchtime library would give pupils a calm place to relax after a noisy morning. Third, pupils could run book swaps, so that everyone finds a book they enjoy.
Would you rather spend lunch in a crowded corridor? Please support this idea, and ask the headteacher to open the library at lunchtime.
Key ideas
- A persuasive text states an opinion, and it wants the reader to agree or act.
- Give clear reasons; a fact can support a reason, but an opinion is what the writer thinks.
- Words such as should show what the writer thinks ought to happen.
- A rhetorical question makes the reader think about the answer.
- A call to action ends the text by asking the reader to do something.
Method. Find the sentence that gives what the writer thinks.
- Find the first sentence. The opinion is usually stated early in the text.Our school library should stay open at lunchtime.
- Check it is an opinion. Should shows what the writer thinks ought to happen, so it is an opinion.should stay open
- Confirm the paragraph. The opinion is in the first paragraph of the text.the first paragraph
- Write the answer. Our school library should stay open at lunchtime.
Check. The first sentence states the opinion. ✓
Method. Find the word Third, then copy the reason that follows it.
- Find Third. The third reason comes after the word Third.Third,
- Copy the reason. The reason is that pupils could run book swaps.pupils could run book swaps
- Write the whole reason. Copy the words to the end of the sentence.pupils could run book swaps, so that everyone finds a book they enjoy
- Write the answer. pupils could run book swaps, so that everyone finds a book they enjoy
Check. The third reason is about book swaps. ✓
Method. Find the last paragraph, then the sentence that asks the reader to act.
- Find the last paragraph. The last paragraph ends the argument.Would you rather spend lunch in a crowded corridor?
- Find the request. Please support this idea asks the reader to act.Please support this idea
- Copy the whole call. The request continues to say what to do.ask the headteacher to open the library at lunchtime
- Write the answer. Please support this idea, and ask the headteacher to open the library at lunchtime.
Check. The call to action asks the reader to do something. ✓
Watch out
Watch out: a persuasive text is not a list of facts with no opinion. State the opinion clearly, and give reasons that the reader can agree with.
Exam tip
Grown-up tip. Ask your child to tell you one thing that they want at home, and to give three reasons for it. Then ask them to end with a request, such as Please let me.
Exercise 12E Practice: persuasive writing
Method. Find the detail that the text states.
- Find the words that answer the question. Scan the text for the detail the question asks about.Our school library should stay open at lunchtime.
- Check that the detail is stated, not guessed. The first sentence gives the opinion that the writer wants the reader to agree with.Our school library should stay open at lunchtime.
- Write the answer. Our school library should stay open at lunchtime.
Check. The text states this detail. ✓
Method. Find the detail that the text states.
- Find the words that answer the question. Scan the text for the detail the question asks about.First, reading helps us learn new words and ideas.
- Check that the detail is stated, not guessed. The reason follows the word First.reading helps us learn new words and ideas
- Write the answer. reading helps us learn new words and ideas
Check. The text states this detail. ✓
Method. Find the detail that the text states.
- Find the words that answer the question. Scan the text for the detail the question asks about.Second, a lunchtime library would give pupils a calm place to relax
- Check that the detail is stated, not guessed. Second begins the reason about a calm place.Second
- Write the answer. Second
Check. The text states this detail. ✓
- Our school library should stay open at lunchtime.
- Would you rather spend lunch in a crowded corridor?
- Reading helps us learn new words and ideas.
Method. Test each choice against the text or the situation.
- Read what the question asks for. Decide what the text or the situation needs.
- Test the choice. It is a question that the writer does not expect the reader to answer aloud; it makes the reader picture the corridor.Would you rather spend lunch in a crowded corridor? fits
- Reject the other choices. The other two sentences are an opinion and a reason, not a question.Our school library should stay open at lunchtime. and Reading helps us learn new words and ideas. do not fit
- Write the answer. Would you rather spend lunch in a crowded corridor?
Check. The choice fits the text or the situation. ✓
Method. Find the detail that the text states.
- Find the words that answer the question. Scan the text for the detail the question asks about.Please support this idea, and ask the headteacher to open the library at lunchtime.
- Check that the detail is stated, not guessed. The last paragraph asks the reader to act.Please support this idea
- Write the answer. Please support this idea
Check. The text states this detail. ✓
Method. Find the detail that the text states.
- Find the words that answer the question. Scan the text for the detail the question asks about.ask the headteacher to open the library at lunchtime
- Check that the detail is stated, not guessed. The call to action names the person who can make the change.headteacher
- Write the answer. headteacher
Check. The text states this detail. ✓
Method. Think about what the writer wants the reader to do.
- Find the request. The writer wants the reader to support the idea.support the idea
- Name the purpose. Trying to make the reader agree is persuading them.to persuade
- Write the answer. to persuade.
Check. The text is written to persuade. ✓
Method. Find the detail that the text states.
- Find the words that answer the question. Scan the text for the detail the question asks about.Our school library should stay open at lunchtime
- Check that the detail is stated, not guessed. Should shows an opinion about what ought to happen.should
- Write the answer. should
Check. The text states this detail. ✓
Method. Find one reason in the text, then say it in your own words.
- Find a reason. The text says a lunchtime library gives a calm place to relax.a calm place to relax
- Say it in your own words. A quiet place helps pupils rest after a noisy morning.a quiet place to rest
- Write the answer. it gives a quiet place to relax after a noisy morning.
Check. The reason is taken from the text and written in your own words. ✓
Method. Think about the effect of a question on the reader.
- Look at the question. Would you rather spend lunch in a crowded corridor? asks the reader to picture a place.picture a crowded corridor
- Think about the reader. A reader who pictures the corridor is more likely to agree with the writer.more likely to agree
- Write the answer. to make the reader picture a crowded corridor and think before deciding.
Check. A question makes the reader think. ✓
Method. Give an opinion with should, then a reason with because.
- Give the opinion. Should shows what ought to happen.should have a bike shelter
- Give the reason. Because gives a reason that the reader can agree with.because many pupils cycle to school
- Write the answer. Our school should have a bike shelter, because many pupils cycle to school.
Check. The sentence has an opinion and a reason. ✓